STARS, PLANETS, MOONS, MINOR PLANETS AND COMETS

Figure 1: Triple protostar system L1448 IRS3B, showing a central binary pair of protostars (IRS3B-A & IRS3B-B, with a combined mass of ∼1 M☉) orbited by a much less massive but much-brighter companion protostar (IRS3B-C, with a mass of ∼0.085 M☉) in a circumbinary orbit.

An alternative ideology, presented here, suggests that the luminosity difference results from a difference in developmental age, where the diminutive C-component was the more-developed former protostellar core of the system and the much-more-massive twin components (IRS3B-A & IRS3B-B) formed by bilateral disk fragmentation in a process designated symmetrical flip-flop fragmentation (symmetrical FFF). Then by chaotic interplay, the system turned itself inside out, with the more-developed former protostellar core becomming the circumbinary companion star.

Image Credit: Bill Saxton, ALMA (ESO/NAOJ/NRAO), NRAO/AUI/NSF – Publication: John Tobin (Univ. Oklahoma/Leiden) et al.

Abstract


    This conceptual study proposes several alternative planet and star formation processes that rapidly project mass inward, accelerating entropy increase over the standard model. The overarching principle might be described as replacing standard-model gradualism with varying degrees of catastrophism.
    A counterintuitive study (Tychoniec et al., 2018) found decreasing accretion disk mass with protostellar evolution.  Disk dust mass was measured to decrease from 248 M⊕ in Class 0 protostars, to 96 M⊕ in Class I protostars, to 5–15 M⊕ in Class II protostars.  This suggests a possible early crossover point, where disk mass could be (much) greater than the central protostar mass, particularly if the trend continues into the prestellar stage.
    In a protostellar system, when the disk mass greatly exceeds its prestellar/protostellar core mass, the disk has inertial dominance and global spiral density waves can form. An m = 1 spiral density wave forms a single asymmetrical spiral arm, and an m = 2 wave forms a symmetrical pair of spiral arms. This study suggests that disk fragmentation forms stellar-mass disk-fragmentation objects rather than planetary-mass objects. Thus, disk fragmentation of m = 1 systems forms solitary stars, designated ‘asymmetrical flip-flop fragmentation’ (‘asymmetrical FFF’), and fragmentation of m = 2 systems forms twin stars, designated ‘symmetrical FFF’.
    In asymmetrical FFF, disk fragmentation forms a stellar-mass disk-fragmentation object (nascent star), which injects (flip-flops) the diminutive, planetary-mass protostellar core into a planetary orbit around the nascent star. Asymmetrical FFF of pseudodisks (feeding the accretion disk) presumably forms cold Jupiters; however, hot Jupiters appear to be a special case. After correcting for observational incompleteness, Zink & Howard (2023) conclude that hot Jupiters are almost invariably accompanied by an outer cold Jupiter. A plausible explanation is that primary accretion disks do not undergo asymmetrical FFF, but truncated secondary accretion disks formed from asymmetrical FFF of pseudodisks may undergo next-generation asymmetrical FFF to form hot Jupiters.
    In symmetrical FFF, forming twin stars, the diminutive protostellar core is not automatically injected into a planetary orbit. Instead, it undergoes a period of chaotic orbital interplay with the twin stars, which are born in an unstable nonhierarchical orbit around the diminutive protostar. During this interplay, the diminutive protostar may be ejected from the system or ‘evaporated’ into a circumbinary orbit around the binary. Brown dwarfs appear to represent a bimodal population, with a scarcity in the 30–55 Mⱼ range (Unger et al., 2023). This suggests that the low-mass population, extending down into the giant planet range, may form by the symmetrical FFF of primary accretion disks, and the high-mass population, extending up into the low-mass red dwarf range, may form by the symmetrical FFF of pseudodisks. Continued interaction with the former accretion disk and possible continuing infall from the envelope can harden the twin binary or cause the binary components to spiral in and merge, forming a solitary star.
    A third planet formation mechanism may be quite rare. In symmetrical FFF systems, when protostellar cores are born spinning so fast that they are distorted into a triaxial Jacobi ellipsoid shape, tidal interactions during orbital interplay may spin up these cores to the point of centrifugal fragmentation. Triaxial objects can tumble in addition to rotating around their primary spin axis, and tidal interactions during orbital close encounters may increase their rate of tumbling, which can be translated into increasing the primary rotation rate. When a companion is internally differentiated, centrifugal fragmentation may take the form of ‘trifurcation’ into three components, consisting of a twin pair in an unstable orbit around the diminutive residual core at the center of rotation. This triple system resembles the original symmetrical FFF system, and so by symmetry, first-generation trifurcation promotes second-generation trifurcation, etc., potentially forming twin planets in diminishing sizes (and increasing elemental densities) like Russian nesting dolls. Thus, our solar system presumably underwent symmetrical FFF, followed by four generations of trifurcation as follows:
    1. Symmetrical FFF—forming ‘Binary-Sun’ (twin disk-fragmentation objects) + ‘Brown Dwarf’ (protostellar core)
    2. 1st-generation trifurcation―forming ‘Binary-Companion’ + ‘SUPER-Jupiter’ (residual core)
    3. 2nd-generation trifurcation—forming Jupiter–Saturn + ‘SUPER-Neptune’ (residual core)
    4. 3rd-generationi trifurcation—forming Uranus–Neptune + ‘SUPER-Earth’ (residual core)
    5. 4th-generation trifurcation—forming Venus–Earth + Mercury (residual core)
This accounting leaves out Mars, which presumably formed by ‘hybrid accretion’ like super-Earths, with ‘hybrid’ indicating hierarchical accretion of ~100 km diameter planetesimals formed by gravitational collapse via the streaming instability.
    During and immediately following the trifurcation epoch, resonance chasing by binary twins caused them to spiral out of the gravitational wells of their ‘parent’ and ‘grandparent’ systems until they were captured by former Binary-Sun into heliocentric orbits. And the sibling twin binary pairs spiraled out from their binary barycenters until they separated to form solitary planets—all except for Binary-Companion. Ultimately, Binary-Sun spiraled in and merged at 4,567 Ma, with spallation nucleosynthesis forming some of the short-lived radionuclides of our early solar system, notably ²⁶Al, ⁴¹Ca and ¹⁰Be. Stellar merger debris, along with continuing infall from the natal envelope, forms the ‘solar-merger debris disk’, which spawned the asteroid belt in situ by gravitational collapse, presumably via the streaming instability.
    Former Binary-Companion presumably orbited between Saturn and Uranus for nearly 4 billion years. Secular perturbation by the Sun caused the super-Jupiter-mass binary components to slowly spiral in, transferring their binary energy into progressively increasing the period of the heliocentric orbit. This progressive increase in heliocentric period caused its 4:1 mean-motion resonance to sweep progressively outward through the Kuiper belt, perturbing Kuiper belt objects (KBOs) and causing the late heavy bombardment (LHB) of the inner solar system. Ultimately, the binary components merged at 639 Ma in an asymmetrical merger explosion that imparted the newly merged Companion escape velocity from the Sun. And the resulting ‘Companion-merger debris disk’ spawned the young (639 Ma) cold-classical KBOs and fogged the solar system, causing the Marinoan glaciation on Earth.
………………..

Table of Contents


1. Introduction
2. Hybrid accretion planets and moons
3. Flip-Flop Fragmentation (FFF)
4. Trifurcation by centrifugal fragmentation
5. Trifurcation moons
6. Former Binary-Companion
7. Protostellar disk and 3 debris disks
8. Venusian cataclysm
9. Solar system summary
10. The predictive and explanatory power of FFF-trifurcation ideology
References


1. Introduction


    No sooner had exoplanets been discovered in the 1990s than astronomers set out to categorize them by mass/radius, composition, and orbital period/semimajor axis, while astrophysicists sought to understand their formation processes. Bimodal populations have since emerged in both mass/radius and orbital period/semimajor axis. A mass gap has been interpreted as evidence for distinct formation pathways: Santos et al. (2017) find a relative scarcity (a valley) of gas-giant exoplanets at about 4 Mⱼ and suggest that planets above 4 Mⱼ are dominated by disk instability while those below are dominated by core accretion. Cui et al. (2026) invoke the same dual formation scenario but place the division at ~30 Mⱼ, within the brown-dwarf-desert mass range. Where bimodality appears in orbital period rather than in mass, secondary mechanisms have been proposed: Type II planetary migration and high-eccentricity migration are commonly invoked to explain the close-in orbits of hot Jupiters.
    This study proposes several primary catastrophic processes as alternatives to the widely accepted gradualistic processes—particularly secondary gradualistic processes like planetary migration.
    The first alternative process for forming giant planets, brown dwarfs and some trinary star systems with one low-mass red-dwarf component is a flip-flop process, wherein a diminutive prestellar/prototellar core is flip-flopped into a planetary orbit as a result of a stellar-mass disk fragmentation, which becomes the new nascent star. This form of disk fragmentation can be asymmetrical or symmetrical, forming one star or twin stars, respectively.
    A second alternative planet-formation process appears to be quite rare, which potentially forms planets in twin pairs in descending sizes like Russian nesting dolls from a brown-dwarf-mass protostar precursor. This process, designated ‘trifurcation’, entails centrifugal fragmentation of a brown-dwarf-mass protostellar into three components, induced by tidal spin up by twin stars formed by the symmetrical flip-flop process. And trifurcation of a brown-dwarf-mass protostar promotes next-generation trifurcation of the tertiary residual core of the previous-generation trifurcation and etc., which is the hypothesized process for the formation of the 3-sets of twin planets in our highly unusual solar system, namely Jupiter-Saturn, Uranus-Neptune and Venus-Earth + Mercury.
    Thirdly, the scientific community seems to be warming to a catastrophic origin of small solar system bodies (SSSBs) by gravitational collapse via streaming instability. Contact binaries and wide binary Kuiper belt objects (KBOs) of comparable mass may be best explained by gravitational collapse (Nesvorný et al., 2010).

Hybrid accretion planets and moons § 2:
    Chains of super-Earths and chains of well-ordered moons around giant planets are suggested here to have formed by ‘hybrid accretion’, which is a hybrid mechanism consisting hierarchical accretion of planetesimals formed by streaming instability.
    Planetesimals that form by streaming instability at pressure bumps, particularly at the truncated inner edge of protoplanetary disks, may accrete to form planets, which may clear their orbits when attaining the nominal mass of a super-Earth.
    And super-Earth formed at the inner edge of a protoplanetary disk that clears its orbit pushes the inner edge of the protoplanetary disk outward, which may spawn a second generation of planetesimals by streaming instability against its strongest outer resonances, which may accrete to form a second super-Earth. In this way, chains of super-Earths and chains of moons around giant planets may form sequentially from the inside out by hybrid accretion.

Flip-Flop Fragmentation (FFF) § 3:

    ‘Flip-flop fragmentation (FFF) or disk fragmentation is an alternative hypothesis for the formation of star systems with gaseous planets, brown dwarfs, and low-mass red dwarfs. The commonality in systems formed by FFF is one or more diminutive gaseous components, presumably spanning the range of mini-Neptunes to low-mass red dwarf stars. In this model, the diminutive low-mass giant planet, brown dwarf or red-dwarf star forms as the central protostellar core, and the much-more-massive host star or twin stars form by stellar-mass disk fragmentation, with the resulting mass inversion turning the system inside out (flip-flopping). And multiple instances of FFF may result in multiple former protostellar cores in planetary orbits around the host star or twin binary stars.

Special terminology:
– Protostellar core: Denotes either the central protostar or the central core of a younger prestellar object.
– Protostellar disk: Denotes either a rotationally supported accretion disk or the compact inner envelope surrounding an accretion disk, commonly called a pseudodisk.
– Asymmetrical FFF: The gravitational fragmentation of an accretion disk into a solitary, stellar-mass disk-fragmentation object (nascent star), with a diminutive protostellar core.
– Symmetrical FFF: The gravitational fragmentation of an accretion disk into twin, stellar-mass disk-fragmentation objects (nascent twin stars), with a diminutive protostellar core.

    The working model for asymmetrical FFF is an m = 1 spiral density wave in either an accretion disk or a pseudodisk, with stellar-mass disk fragmentation forming a nascent star that flip-flops the diminutive protostellar core into a planetary orbit. Asymmetrical FFF of pseudodisks form ‘cold Jupiters’ and low-mass brown dwarfs in longer-period orbits than asymmetrical FFF of accretion disks. Hot Jupiters appear to be a special case, formed by asymmetrical FFF of secondary accretion disks formed from the aftermath of an earlier protostellar disk fragmentation. Asymmetrical FFF may form satellites that range from mini-Neptunes to low-mass brown dwarfs around solitary stars.

    The working model for symmetrical FFF is an m = 2 spiral density wave in either a primary accretion disk or a pseudodisk, forming twin, stellar-mass disk-fragmentation objects in addition to the diminutive central protostar (companion) in the high-mass brown dwarf to low-mass red dwarf range. Then orbital interplay causes the twin stars to form a binary pair, ejecting the former companion or ‘evaporating’ it into a circumbinary orbit around the twin binary stars. Furthermore, orbital interplay along with continuing infall from the stellar envelope may induce the twin components to spiral in and merge.

Trifurcation § 4:
    The three sets of twin planets in our highly-unusual solar system (Jupiter-Saturn, Uranus-Neptune and Venus-Earth + Mercury) are proposed to have formed like Russian nesting dolls in successive generations of a dynamic mechanism designated ‘trifurcation’. This study suggests a symmetrical FFF origin for our solar system, with a diminutive protostellar core in the high-mass brown dwarf range (> 30 Mⱼ), designated ‘Brown-Dwarf’. The twin stellar-mass disk-fragmentation objects became our former ‘Binary-Sun’. Then the trinary system underwent a multi-generational trifurcation process.
    Central protostellar cores may be born with sufficient angular momentum to be spun up into a triaxial Jacobi ellipsoid shape, and a Jacobi ellipsoid can tumble chaotically in addition to spinning around its principal rotation axis. In an orbital close encounter between a diminutive protostar (as a Jacobi ellipsoid) and one of its much-more-massive twin siblings, the chaotic tumbling rate may be sub-synchronous while the spin rate is super-synchronous, and a sub-synchronous tumbling rate at periapsis raises a lagging tidal bulge that is pulled forward by the host body, increasing the tumbling rate, which can be translated into increasing the rotation rate. Thus in orbital close encounters during chaotic interplay between Brown-Dwarf and the twin stellar components of Binary-Sun, Brown dwarf may have been spun up to the point of centrifugal fragmentation.
    Standard modeling of centrifugal fission yields bifurcation (two bodies), not trifurcation (three bodies); however, this study suggests that when the body is internally differentiated, with denser material in the core, the result may be trifurcation, resulting in a diminutive ‘residual core’ remaining at the center of rotation in addition to the essentially bifurcated twin components. And a newly trifurcated system composed of a twin pair in orbit around a diminutive core is a miniature version of the original symmetrical FFF system, which by symmetry is subject to next-generation trifurcation.
    In this manner, our former symmetrical FFF system presumably underwent four generations of trifurcation, forming
– 1st-gen: ‘Binary-Companion’ + ‘SUPER-Jupiter’ (residual core)
– 2nd-gen: Jupiter & Saturn + ‘SUPER-Neptune’ (residual core)
– 3rd-gen: Uranus & Neptune + ‘SUPER-Earth’ (residual core)
– 4th-gen: Venus & Earth + Mercury (residual core)
    The resulting ‘trifurcation debris disk’ spawned the hot classical Kuiper belt objects (KBOs). And binary-binary resonances with former Binary-Sun caused Jupiter-Saturn, Uranus-Neptune and Venus-Earth to spiral out and separate, leaving only former Binary-Sun and former Binary-Companion as binary subsystems. Former Binary-Sun spiraled in and merged at 4,567 Ma in a luminous red nova, creating the ‘solar-merger debris disk’ that spawned the asteroids. And former Binary-Companion spiraled in and merged at 639 Ma in an asymmetrical merger explosion that gave the newly merged Companion escape velocity from the Sun, and the merger explosion formed the ‘Companion-merger debris disk’ that spawned the cold-classical KBOs.

Trifurcation moons and the Venusian cataclysm § 4, § 5:
    Trifurcation may be slightly more complex than the simplistic mechanism outlined above, which is expressed in a more complete form as the ‘trifurcation+2’ mechanism. In computer simulations, bar-mode instabilities have tails trailing from the twin ends of the central bar, which are suggested here to self-gravitate and form a twin pair of moons. ‘Trifurcation moons’ are stillborn, in a sense, being born without kinetic energy or angular momentum with respect to their respective twin planetary components, to which they are gravitationally bound. But due to the extreme dynamics of the trifurcation+2 subsystem within the greater system that induced trifurcation, the moons quickly acquire angular momentum with respect to the planets to which they are gravitationally bound, necessarily injecting one moon into a prograde orbit and its twin moon into a retrograde orbit. Thus, in the 4th generation trifurcation, Earth acquired its oversized trifurcation Moon (Luna) in a prograde orbit, and Venus acquired an oversized trifurcation moon in a retrograde orbit.
    This is the present and former list of trifurcation moons:
– Neptune with retrograde Triton
– Uranus with a former prograde moon
– Saturn with prograde Titan
– Jupiter with a former retrograde moon
– Earth with prograde Luna
-Venus with a former retrograde moon
    Jupiter’s former retrograde moon may have spiraled in and merged with the planet at 4,562 Ma, forming enstatite chondrites that lie on the terrestrial fractionation line. Uranus presumably lost all its original moons, including its prograde trifurcation moon, in orbital close encounters with former Binary-Companion, and later spawned a young set of hybrid-accretion moons from the 639 Ma Companion-merger debris disk. And finally, Venus’ former retrograde trifurcation moon spiraled in and merged with the planet, presumably at 579 Ma, causing the ‘Venusian cataclysm’ which completely resurfaced the planet and caused Venus’ slight retrograde rotation, as well as presumably causing Gaskiers glaciation on Earth.

Star formation stages:
    1. Starless core: May be a transient phase or may progress to Jeans instability.
    2. Prestellar core: The initial collapse phase ends when the core becomes optically thick, forming a pressure-supported first hydrostatic core (FHSC). The FHSC phase ends when molecular hydrogen endothermically dissociates into atomic hydrogen around 2000 K, causing a brief second collapse. The FHSC marks the end of the prestellar phase.
    3. Protostar (Class 0, I, II, III): Begins with the collapse of the FHSC, designated the ‘second collapse’, which creates a second hydrostatic core (SHSC).
    4. Pre-main-sequence star: A T Tauri, FU Orionis, or larger pre-main-sequence star powered by gravitational contraction.
    5. Main-sequence star: Powered by hydrogen fusion.

    “Starless cores are possibly transient concentrations of molecular gas and dust without embedded young stellar objects (YSOs), typically observed in tracers such as C18O (e.g. Onishi et al. 1998), NH3 (e.g. Jijina, Myers, & Adams 1999), or dust extinction (e.g. Alves et al. 2007), and which do not show evidence of infall. Prestellar cores are also starless (M⋆ = 0) but represent a somewhat denser and more centrally-concentrated population of cores which are self-gravitating, hence unlikely to be transient.” (André et al. 2008)

    In Jeans instability, the cloud collapses at an approximately free-fall rate nearly isothermally at about 10 K until the center become optically thick at ~10-13 g/cm3 after 105 yr (Larson 1969).  When the center becomes optically thick, the temperature begins to rise, forming a FHSC. “Numerical results for a typical case … show that the radius and mass of the first core are ~5 AU and ~0.05 M☉, respectively. These values are independent both of the mass of the parent cloud core and of the initial density profile.” When the temperature reaches about 2000 K, the hydrogen begins to dissociate endothermically, forming the second core, the birth of a protostar. The protostar grows in mass by accreting the infalling material from the circumstellar envelope, while the protostar keeps its radius at ~4 R☉ during the main accretion phase. (Masunaga et al. 1998)
    Vaytet et al. (2013) finds a variable first core, but a standard size for the second core. “The size of the first core was found to vary somewhat in the different simulations (more unstable clouds form smaller first cores) while the size, mass, and temperature of the second cores are independent of initial cloud mass, size, and temperature.
Conclusions. Our simulations support the idea of a standard (universal) initial second core size of ~3×10-3 AU and mass ~1.4×10-3 M☉.”
(Vaytet et al. 2013)
    A relatively consistent modest mass for the first collapse, the FHSC, and the early SHSC could allow for an oversized protellar disk to have inertial dominance of the system, promoting disk fragmentation.

FHSC:

    The development of a bar mode and spiral structure is expected for rapidly rotating polytropic-like structures (e.g. Durisen et al. 1986). Such instabilities occur when the ratio of the rotational energy to the magnitude of the gravitational potential energy of the first core exceeds β = 0.274. Bate was also the first to point out that because a rapidly rotating first core develops into a disc before the stellar core forms, the disc forms before the star. Rather than hydrostatic cores, such structures are better described as ‘pre-stellar discs’.
    Without rotation (β = 0), the first core has an initial mass of ≈5 MJ and a radius of ≈5 au (in agreement with Larson 1969). However, with higher initial rotation rates of the molecular cloud core, the first cores become progressively more oblate. For example, with β = 0.005 using radiation hydrodynamics, before the onset of dynamical instability, the first core has a radius of ≈20 au and a major-to-minor-axis ratio of ≈4:1. With β = 0.01, the first core has a radius of ≈30 au and a major-to-minor-axis ratio of ≈6:1. Thus, for the higher rotation rates, the first core is actually a pre-stellar disc, without a central object. As pointed out by Bate (1998), Machida et al. (2010) and Bate (2010), the disc actually forms before the star. For the very highest rotation rates (β = 0.04), the first core actually takes the form of a torus or ring in which the central density is lower than the maximum density.
    In each of the β = 0.001–0.005 cases, the first core begins as an axisymmetric flattened pre-stellar disc, but after several rotations, it develops a bar mode. The ends of the bar subsequently lag behind and the bar winds up to produce a spiral structure. Spiral structure removes angular momentum from the inner parts of the first core via gravitational torques (Bate 1998).

(Matthew R. Bate, 2011)

    “Class 0 objects are the youngest accreting protostars observed right after point mass formation, when most of the mass of the system is still in the surrounding dense core/envelope (Andre et al. 2000).”
(Chen et al. 2012)

    “Enoch et al. (2009a) discovered a massive circumstellar disk of ∼1 M☉ comparable to a central protostar around a Class 0 object, indicating that (1) the disk already exists in the main accretion phase and (2) the disk mass is significantly larger than the theoretical
prediction.” (Machida et al. 2011)

Evidence for Kuiper belt objects (KBOs) formed by gravitational/streaming instability:
    “The 100 km class binary KBOs identified so far are widely separated and their components are similar in size. These properties defy standard ideas about processes of binary formation involving collisional and rotational disruption, debris re-accretion, and tidal evolution of satellite orbits
(Stevenson et al. 1986).” “The observed color distribution of binary KBOs can be easily understood if KBOs formed by GI [gravitational instability].” “We envision a situation in which the excess of angular momentum in a gravitationally collapsing swarm prevents formation of a solitary object. Instead, a binary with large specific angular momentum forms from local solids, implying identical composition (and colors) of the binary components.”
(Nesvorny et al. 2010)
………………..

2. Hybrid accretion planets and moons


    ‘Hybrid accretion’ is a working hypothesis for the formation of cascades or chains of well-behaved super-Earths in stellar systems and similar groupings of well-behaved moons around giant planets. This alternative planet formation mechanism combines the formation of planetesimals by streaming instability with the hierarchical accretion of these planetesimals into super-Earths or moons, hence the term “hybrid” accretion.
    This hybrid mechanism for planet formation was first proposed for the formation of gas giant planets by Thayne Curie (2005), but is proposed here for the formation cascades of super-Earths and similar cascades of moons.

    In protostellar disks, gas rotates at a sub-Keplerian rate due to pressure support, while dust particles, which do not experience pressure forces, must orbit at the Keplerian rate to maintain a stable orbit. The difference in rotational speeds creates a drag force on the dust, causing it to lose angular momentum and spiral inward. This process can lead to the accumulation of dust at regions of higher pressure, known as ‘pressure bumps.’ If the dust density at these bumps becomes high enough, it may trigger the streaming instability—a type of gravitational instability that can enhance dust clumping and potentially lead to planetesimal formation.
    This study suggests the sequential inside-out formation of hybrid-accretion cascades, where the innermost hybrid accretion object presumably forms at a pressure bump that constitutes the inner edge of the accretion disk, which is controlled by the magnetospheric radius, where the pressure from the star’s magnetic field balances the dynamic pressure of the accreting material in the disk. At the pressure bump constituting the inner edge of the accretion disk, streaming instability may form zillions of ~ 100 km planetesimals, which merge by hierarchical accretion until attaining sufficient mass to clear the orbit. Around a star, a hybrid accretion object must attain the nominal mass of a super-Earth to clear its orbit and create a new inner edge to the protoplanetary disk. Then a new round of planetesimal formation can commence, in or between the strongest outer mean motion resonances (MMRs) of the new hybrid-accretion object. In this way, the innermost (anchor) hybrid accretion object spawns a second hybrid accretion object against its strongest outer resonances and so forth, which may form a chain of hybrid-accretion objects from the inside out, like peas-in-a-pod.
    Hybrid accretion moons may similarly form around giant planets. The 5 planemo moons of Uranus (Miranda, Ariel, Umbriel, Titania and Oberon) are perhaps the best example of a well-behaved moony hybrid-accretion cascade in our solar system.

    Sourav Chatterjee and Jonathan C. Tan quantified this form of inside-out planet formation mechanism in a more general form, encompassing either pebble accretion or ∼1 M⊕ planet formation by gravitational instability. “Formation of a series of super-Earth mass planets from pebbles could require initial protoplanetary disks extending to ∼100 AU.” (Chatterjee and Tan 2013)

    In chains of super-Earths, the outermost planetary pair typically exhibits a greater period ratio than the other adjacent planetary pairs in the same stellar system. This may lend support to inside-out formation mechanism, where only the outermost last-forming super-Earth has not experienced a significant degree of inward migration due to the inward pressure of truncating a massive accretion disk against its outer resonances. See Table 1 for a comparison of the period ratios for 2 chains of super-Earths.

Relative orbital period ratios of adjacent super-Earths in two exoplanet systems

Table 1. Orbital period ratios of adjacent super-Earths. Note the greater orbital period ratio between the outermost adjacent super-Earth pairs (red) compared to inner adjacent super-Earth pairs (blue)
………………..

3. Flip-Flop Fragmentation (FFF)


    ‘Flip-flop fragmentation (FFF) or (disk) fragmentation is an alternative hypothesis for the formation of star systems with gas giant planets and brown dwarfs.  It may also explain some multiple star systems with great mass disparity between the components.
    By definition, ‘protostellar core’ denotes either the central protostar or the central core of a younger prestellar object, while ‘protostellar disk’ refers to either a rotationally supported accretion disk or the compact inner envelope (‘pseudodisk’) surrounding an accretion disk.  And ‘disk’ used without an adjective modifier presumes a protostellar disk (accretion disk or pseudodisk).
    Note: Whether non-rotationally supported pseudodisks can sustain global gravitational eigenmodes (manifesting as spiral density waves) or global MHD modes has not yet been established in the literature. Nevertheless, this study has adopted spiral density waves in pseudodisks as the convenient working hypothesis. Alternatively, localized fragmentation driven by transient gravitational or magnetic instabilities could produce similar outcomes.
    As formulated here, FFF has two forms (asymmetrical and symmetrical) and two classes, distinguished by whether fragmentation occurs in the accretion disk or the more distant pseudodisk. The two forms arise from m = 1 and m = 2 spiral density waves, which gravitationally fragment protostellar disks to form either one star (asymmetrical FFF) or two stars (symmetrical FFF).  One further distinction discriminates between primary accretion disks and secondary accretion disks formed from the aftermath of a previous instance of FFF. The outcomes of two of the above permuations have not been identified, that of asymmetrical FFF of primary accretion disks and that of symmetrical FFF of secondary accretion disks. These two unidentified permutations could be rare, nonexistent, or not yet identified as such.
    The flip-flop component of the theory arises from the gravitational dynamics of systems with a lopsided disk-to-core mass ratio. When the protostellar disk substantially outweighs its central protostellar core, this study proposes that the system can undergo a catastrophic flip-flop into a more dynamically stable configuration through gravitational fragmentation of the disk. Thus, FFF increases entropy by catastrophically projecting mass inward by gravitational collapse.
    In asymmetrical FFF, gravitational fragmentation of the disk automatically displaces the former protostellar core into a planetary orbit, birthing a stable hierarchical system, whereas in symmetrical FFF, the system is born unstable and nonhierarchical, with twin disk-fragmentation objects (nascent stars) initially orbiting the diminutive protostellar core. Therefore, symmetrical FFF requires a subsequent epoch of orbital interplay to dynamically evolve into a stable hierarchical system. In both cases, the original protostellar core is displaced (flip-flopped) into a satellite status, which dynamically evolves into a circumbinary orbit in symmetrical FFF. This study proposes that asymmetrical FFF of pseudodisks yields cold Jupiters and that subsequent asymmetrical FFF of secondary accretion disks formed from the aftermath of pseudodisk fragmentation yields hot Jupiters, including the gaseous diminutives down to mini-Neptunes. And gaseous planet multiplicity, not due to trifurcation or hybrid accretion, results from sequential FFF episodes. Symmetrical FFF yields trinary systems with a massive twin binary and a diminutive circumbinary component (the former protostar), with the Alpha Centauri system as the prototype for pseudodisk fragmentation. Our Solar System may have formed by symmetrical FFF of a primary accretion disk. Then following FFF, our Solar System underwent four generations of trifurcation (§ 4), and following the trifurcation epoch, the twin stellar components of our former ‘Binary-Sun’ spiraled in and merged at 4,567 Ma to form our solitary Sun.

A counterintuitive protostellar disk discovery:
    Planet formation theory is constrained by the mass and evolution of protostellar disks. A counterintuitive finding (Tychoniec et al., 2018) measured decreasing dust mass—assumed to be a proxy for overall disk mass—with protostellar evolution: from 248 M⊕ in Class 0 protostars, to 96 M⊕ in Class I, to 5–15 M⊕ in Class II. Tychoniec et al. (2018) does not definitely discriminate between a rotationally-supported disk and a ‘compact inner envelope’ (pseudodisk).
    If the youngest protostars have the most massive disks, a reasonable extrapolation suggests that still-younger prestellar objects may have even more massive disks. Since protostars steadily accrete while their surrounding disks rapidly dissipate, these opposing trends imply an early crossover point, before which disks may be substantially more massive than their protostellar cores, resulting in dynamically unstable systems. As Li et al. (2014) note: “The compact components around the Class 0 protostars could be the precursors to these Keplerian disks. However, it is unlikely that such massive rotationally supported disks could be stably supported given the expected low stellar mass for the Class 0 protostars: they should be prone to fragmentation.”
    A separate study of 90 protostellar systems finds the highest dust opacity in the youngest Class 0 disks (Hsieh et al., 2025), where optical depth presumably correlates with disk mass.

Asymmetrical FFF:
    The Tychoniec et al. (2018) trend suggests an early crossover point at which the disk mass may (greatly) exceed that of the central protostellar core. When disk mass greatly exceeds protostellar core mass, the disk’s self-gravity dominates the system’s dynamics, and perturbations become governed primarily by the disk’s own gravitational potential rather than that of the central object. In a core-dominated system, disk rotation is approximately Keplerian, modified by gaseous pressure support. As the disk becomes increasingly self-gravitating, however, the rotational profile departs from Keplerian behavior. Toomre’s Q criterion provides the standard criterion for local gravitational instability, but for sufficiently massive disks the local approximation underlying the analysis becomes progressively less applicable, and global gravitational modes may become dynamically dominant. If a strongly asymmetric inhomogeneity comes to dominate the disk, it may progressively displace the original protostellar core from the system’s dynamical center, ending its accretional phase. The disk’s self-gravity—rather than acting as a passive Keplerian reservoir around a dominant central object—comes to dominate the gravitational potential. This dominance permits the growth of large-scale non-axisymmetric modes, particularly the m = 1 spiral instability, whose nonlinear evolution can drive global fragmentation. A stellar-mass fragment may then condense from the disk to become the primary gravitating body, while the original planetary-mass protostellar core survives as a planetary satellite orbiting the newly formed star. Moreover, star formation through disk fragmentation may proceed substantially faster than the original Jeans collapse because the gas and dust within protostellar disks are already orders of magnitude denser than those in the parent molecular cloud.

Hot Jupiters by secondary fragmentation:
    The term ‘hot Jupiter’ appeared shortly after the discovery of 51 Pegasi b in 1995. It refers to a planet that has roughly the mass of Jupiter, orbits extremely close to its host star (typically <0.1 AU), and has equilibrium temperatures of roughly 1000–3000 K. The term ‘cold Jupiter’ came later and is less formally defined as a Jupiter-mass planet in a more distant cooler orbit. Unlike hot Jupiter, which describes a distinct observational class, cold Jupiter is mainly a convenient contrast.
    A recent finding may irrevocably couple hot Jupiters with cold Jupiters. Zink & Howard (2023) discovered a fundamental characteristic of gas-giant planet systems that may telegraph their formation process. After correcting for observational incompleteness, they conclude that hot Jupiters are almost invariably accompanied by an outer cold Jupiter. As they state,
“while not all hot Jupiters have a detected outer giant planet companion (M sin i = 0.3–30 MJup), such companions are ubiquitous when survey completeness corrections are applied for orbital periods out to 40,000 days.”
I.e., all systems with a hot Jupiter also contain a cold Jupiter. Secondly, they found that the outer giant planet companions are at least 3× more massive than the inner hot Jupiters. And thirdly, they found that,
“the eccentricity distribution of the outer companions in hot Jupiter systems (with an average model eccentricity of (⟨e⟩ = 0.34 ± 0.05) is different from the corresponding outer planets in planetary systems without hot Jupiters (⟨e⟩ = 0.19 ± 0.02).”
These combined observations suggest that hot Jupiters are not isolated objects but instead represent one component of a two-planet architecture.
    Zink & Howard (2023) built on Petrovich’s (2015) model for producing hot Jupiters through a two-planet process termed Coplanar High-eccentricity Migration (CHEM). In Petrovich’s model, secular gravitational interactions between two eccentric giant planets with low mutual inclination drive the inner planet to extreme eccentricity, after which tidal dissipation circularizes its orbit close to the host star. Zink & Howard provided observational support for this mechanism, finding that hot Jupiters with detected outer giant companions exhibit a pronounced mass hierarchy, M_outer/M_HJ ≳ 3—somewhat stronger than Petrovich’s preferred mass hierarchy—and demonstrating through forward modeling that observational selection effects are unlikely to account for it. They further inferred from the California Legacy Survey that outer giant companions may be ubiquitous among hot-Jupiter systems after correcting for survey incompleteness. Thus, Petrovich demonstrated a viable two-planet mechanism for producing hot Jupiters, while Zink & Howard found evidence that hot-Jupiter systems possess the type of two-planet architecture required by that mechanism.
    This twin hot & cold architecture with mass disparity suggests a two stage process within the FFF framework, wherein primary pseudodisk fragmentation triggers secondary accretion disk fragmentation. The pseudodisk fragmentation produces the more-massive cold Jupiter and the secondary accretion disk fragmentation produces the less-massive warm-hot Jupiter. Primary pseudodisk fragmentation presumably creates a massive reservoir of low-to-moderate specific-angular-momentum gas and dust that quickly spawns an unusually massive secondary accretion disk that may be subject to secondary fragmentation. And the secondary accretion-disk fragmentation may kick the cold Jupiter from the primary pseudodisk fragmentation into a high-eccentricity orbit, compatible with the dynamic CHEM requirements.
    The > 3:1 cold-to-hot mass ratio “[e]vidence” by Zink & Howard indicates a system parameter that carries through from primary pseudodisk fragmentation to secondary accretion disk fragmentation. And a parameter likely to remain approximately conserved throughout this double-fragmentation sequence is specific angular momentum. Higher specific angular momentum should partition more mass into the accretion disk and correspondingly less into the protostellar core and vice versa, making specific angular momentum inversely proportional to gas-giant planet mass in a way that should carry through from primary pseudodisk fragmentation to secondary accretion disk fragmentation, correlating hot and cold Jupiter masses within the same system.
    So, specific angular momentum within a system presumably carries through from primary pseudodisk fragmentation to secondary accretion disk fragmentation, but variable specific angular momentum between systems may have implications as well. In Fig. 2, hot Jupiters are clustered along the top diagonal line segment demarcating the triangular-shaped exoplanet desert. The negative slope of this hot Jupiter constitutes an inverse co between mass and orbital period/semimajor axis. This is compatible with variable specific angular momentum between systems, where higher specific angular momentum creates larger-diameter accretion disks with lower-mass secondary protostellar cores, tending to displace less-massive hot Jupiters into higher orbits, while lower specific angular momentum tends to inject more-massive hot Jupiters into lower, hotter orbits. This inverse relationship is a natural outcome of variable specific angular momentum without invoking the CHEM process. So, while FFF is not incompatible with the CHEM process, it may not require it.
    Bimodal populations may be more cogently explained by separate discrete origins than by a single origin, subsequently split by a secondary mechanism. Wittenmyer et al. (2010) discovered that the hot and cold Jupiter populations are separated by a 10–100 d giant-planet orbital-period valley, indicating non-overlapping bimodal populations. In the core accretion standard model, higher metallicity accelerates core formation, allowing giant planets to form while the disk is still massive, thereby enhancing Type II migration, producing a population of hot Jupiters around metal-rich stars. But to reproduce the observed orbital-period valley, core accretion would require an additional fine-tuned parameter or secondary mechanism, such as a metallicity threshold for migration or a disk-truncation mechanism that selectively halts inward migration. The secondary Petrovich CHEM process alternative to Type II migration may have the same difficulty in reproducing true bimodal populations, with the additional difficulty of reproducing the elevated metallicity of hot Jupiter host stars, as we will see. Alternatively, separate origins for hot (secondary accretion disk) and cold (pseudodisk) planets naturally lend itself to a bimodal distribution, if not outright predicting it, and without fine tuning or secondary mechanisms.
    Banerjee et al., (2024) discovered that the host stars of hot Jupiters are relatively metal rich ([Fe/H] = 0.18 ± 0.13), while the host stars of cold Jupiters are relatively metal poor ([Fe/H] = 0.03 ± 0.18), indicating that the bimodal aspect of the gas-giant-exoplanet populations extends to the host stars themselves. In the core accretion standard model, Type II planetary migration may neatly explain the elevated metallicity of hot Jupiter host stars due to elevated metallicity forming giant planets more quickly when the disk is still massive enough for angular-momentum exchange between gaseous planets and disks to promote Type II migration. Alternatively, the two-planet Zink & Howard architecture has the baffling burden of reproducing the Banerjee et al. (2024) host-star metallicity disparity from the >3:1 cold/hot mass ratio and orbital characteristics necessary for the CHEM dynamics. FFF has the much-lower burden of needing to demonstrate that accretion disks have greater metallicity than pseudodisks. Accretion disks can develop locally enhanced dust-to-gas ratios relative to their parent envelopes as dust settles toward the disk midplane, and if this dust-enriched material is preferentially incorporated into disk fragmentation objects, then stars formed by accretion-disk fragmentation should exhibit higher average metallicities than stars formed by pseudodisk fragmentation, and specifically secondary accretion disks for hot Jupiters.

Four Jupiter mass (Mj) giant-planet valley:
    Santos et al. (2017) finds a relative scarcity (a valley) of gas-giant exoplanets, with a mass of about 4 Mj (Fig. 3). They suggest that the valley may be the result of bimodal giant planet populations, with planets > 4 Mj dominated by disk instability and planets < 4 Mj dominated by the core accretion process. This represents an ad hoc splintering of the standard model to explain a single phenomenon; however, in fairness the same could be said for the FFF model to explain hot and cold Jupiters; however, hot and cold Jupiters represent definite bimodal populations, whereas the 4 Mj scarcity appears to be more of a narrow mass deficit than bimodal populations. Additionally, Santos et al. (2017) notes a metallicity divide in the host stars across the 4 Mj boundary, with elevated metallicity below the boundary, but they make no orbital period distinction in that regard, such that a higher percentage of hot Jupiters below the boundary may explain away the metallicity difference. By comparison, the alternative FFF model points to a developmental phase at the transition between prestellar (< 4 Mj) and protostellar (> 4 Mj) cores: that of the first hydrostatic core (FHSC).
    The most significant event during prestellar collapse is the formation of the FHSC, which temporarily arrests core collapse through thermal-pressure support. The FHSC represents a brief intermediate stage between the nearly isothermal collapse of the prestellar core and the formation of the protostar. As gas falls onto a prestellar core, its potential energy is radiated away as infrared photons until it reaches the critical density of about 10-13 g cm-3, when the prestellar core becomes optically opaque in the infrared, causing its temperature to rise. This temperature rise increases the gas pressure to the point of forming a (first) hydrostatic core. The duration of the FHSC is calculated to last only a few hundred to a few thousand years (Young, 2023), depending on rotation and magnetic fields. As continued accretion raises its central temperature to approximately 2000 K, molecular hydrogen begins to dissociate. Because H₂ dissociation absorbs much of the energy released by compression, the effective adiabatic index falls below that required for hydrostatic stability, triggering the second collapse. This collapse ends with formation of the second hydrostatic core—the nascent protostar.
    Gas falling onto the FHSC from the accretion disk creates a shock front that extends to a radius of ~ 5–10 AU (Tsitali et al. 2013). This study proposes that this extreme pithiness causes the FHSC to viscously engage with the surrounding accretion disk. And this viscous engagement temporarily damps down the positive disk-core feedback necessary for runaway disk fragmentation, resulting in a temporal hiatus in FFF during the brief FHSC phase. And the small accretional mass gain by protostellar cores during the FHSC phase shows up as a deficit (valley) in the mass continuum of gas-giant planets formed by FFF.
    The mass of the FHSC is not well constrained observationally or theoretically, with rotation and magnetic fields greatly increasing its theoretical mass above the simple solution calculated by Larson (1969) of 1 Mj. In another analysis, Bate (2011) predicts a FHSC mass of 5 Mj for nonrotating cores. These two estimates straddle the 4 Mj valley, making the FHSC a reasonable hypothesis.
    Thus, the 4 Mj valley provides a coarse estimate for the average mass of the FHSC phase. The prominence of the valley is a little puzzling for such a brief protostellar core phase, however, since it suggests a significant mass gain during the brief FFF hiatus. Alternatively, the prominence of the valley may indicate that disk inhomogeneities take some time to develop following the actual damping during the brief pithy phase. Additionally, the sharpness of the valley appears to indicate that the flip-flopped protostellar cores do not accrete substantial additional mass following FFF. The presumed viscous engagement during the FHSC phase is between the FHSC and the surrounding accretion disk. but the valley principally shows up in the less-clustered cold Jupiter population, which indicates that the FHSC hiatus in asymmetrical FFF applies to pseudodisk fragmentation, and if pseudodisk fragmentation then certainly secondary accretion disk fragmentation by extension.

 

Exoplanet mass vs. orbital period_20

Figure 2: Log-log plot of planetary mass as a function of orbital period:
– Red lines: Relative desert of giant planets with an orbital period of 10–100 days, separating hot Jupiters from cold Jupiters
– Purple line: Relative desert of giant planets with a mass of 4 Mj
– Black dashed line segments, meeting at a right angle: outlines the planetary desert
– Black lines with arrowheads: indicates formational mass and resulting mass
Image credit: Modified from Mazeh, Holczer and Faigler, A&A 589, A75 (2016), Fig.1


Figure 3: Logarithmic mass distribution of giant planets around solar-type stars. Reproduced from Santos et al. (2017, Fig. 1). Green and blue histograms indicate different selection criteria.


The effect of magnetic fields in forming accretion disks and protostellar disks:

    During the collapse of a prestellar core, nebular magnetic fields channel the infalling gas and dust. An hourglass-shaped field geometry directs material along field lines, creating a flattened envelope—known as a pseudodisk—that forms perpendicular to the field lines around the central core.
    The subsequent evolution depends critically on the angle between the magnetic field and the rotation axis. When the two are aligned, magnetic braking is highly efficient, often suppressing the formation of large, rotationally supported disks (RSDs). This over-efficient braking is known as the “magnetic braking catastrophe,” which may form massive pseudodisks. However, when the field and rotation axis are significantly misaligned, braking becomes less efficient, allowing larger accretion disks to form.
    The HH 212 protostellar system illustrates this interplay. HCO+ emission traces infalling material with slight rotation—i.e., spiraling—in the pseudodisk, which extends to roughly 800 AU. Inside this flattened envelope, a bright compact disk is visible in continuum emission, with an outer radius of about 120 AU (0.3″). This inner disk also appears in HCO+ , and its kinematics confirm that it is rotating. The rotationally supported disk is expected to be Keplerian when the protostar’s mass dominates the disk’s mass.
    A key observational constraint is the density contrast between the pseudodisk and the inner disk: producing the observed continuum emission requires a density jump of roughly a factor of 8, consistent with an isothermal shock at the boundary. This stands in tension with many magnetic collapse models, which predict that efficient magnetic braking should prevent any rotationally supported disk from forming—leaving only the pseudodisk around the protostar. (Lee et al., 2014)
    Thus, pseudodisk fragmentation presumably occurs most readily when the magnetic field and the rotation axis are aligned, forming massive pseudodisks by suppressing the formation of large accretion disks.

Symmetrical FFF:
    Neptune-, Saturn- and Jupiter-mass planets have been discovered in circumbinary orbits, but the overwhelming majority of companion objects in hierarchical trinary systems are low-mass stars. “At least 32 sub-stellar companions orbiting stellar or brown-dwarf binaries have been detected to date.” (Mogan and Zanazzi, 2024) This compares with 5,600 exoplanets overall. In the Mogan and Zanazzi (2024) study, the complete absence of planets around sub-seven-day period binaries indicates the relative difficulty of finding circumbinary planets. And the Gaia spacecraft, which has examined 2 billion stars overall, discovered only 376 new hierarchical triple system candidates in 2022 (Czavalinga et al., 2023), with the stellar companions all having ≲ 1000 day orbital periods. The Gaia survey was not designed to find wide circumbinary companions, but the fact that our nearest neighbor star system, Alpha Centauri, has a wide circumbinary companion with a 550,000 year orbital period, suggests that wide hierarchical triples may be commonplace.
    This study suggests that when well-behaved protostellar disks contain much-greater mass than their protostellar cores, they may be susceptible to m = 2 spiral density waves, which could trigger bilateral disk fragmentation, forming twin stellar-mass disk-fragmentation objects. This raises the question of which class(es) of disk participate in symmetrical FFF. The Unger et al. (2023) study, detailed below, finds that brown dwarfs constitute a bimodal population, with a 30–55 Mj scarcity in between. This bimodal finding points to separate origins for the two populations: primary accretion disks for the low-mass population and pseudodisks for the high-mass population. If hot Jupiters are indeed the result of asymmetrical FFF of secondary-accretion-disks, then perhaps the turbulence inherent in pseudodisk fragmentation is necessary to foster asymmetrical FFF in secondary accretion disks, whereas quiescent conditions in primary accretion disks presumably foster symmetrical FFF.
    Bilateral disk fragmentation forms twin disk-fragmentation objects (nascent stars), born in a dynamically unstable, nonhierarchical orbit around a diminutive protostellar core (companion), creating a trinary system. The much-greater overlying mass of the twin stars is dynamically resolved with orbital interplay between the twin stellar-mass components and the diminutive companion. The companion may range in mass from the upper end of the planetary-mass range through the brown dwarf realm into the lower red dwarf range. But whether the mass of the companion tends to scale with the masses of the twin stars is an open question.
   The mass of former protostellar cores from symmetrical FFF are centered in the brown dwarf range, whereas the mass of former protostellar cores from asymmetrical FFF are centered in the Jupiter-mass range.  This huge mass disparity may be attributable to the mechanism that apparently promotes asymmetrical FFF, which is disk-core feedback.  The 4 Mj valley appears to validate the disk-core feedback mechanism in asymmetrical FFF, such that the protostellar core is necessarily separated from its accretion disk, effectively ending the accretional phase.  By comparison, the bilateral symmetry of symmetrical FFF may largely preclude such feedback, such that the protostellar core may retain its inner accretion disk in symmetrical FFF of accretion disks and may retain an even larger portion of its accretion disk in symmetrical FFF of pseuodisks, thus allowing protostellar cores to continue accreting substantual mass following the fragmentation event, until orbital interplay disrupts the accretion disk.
    Equipartition of kinetic energy in orbital close encounters tends to equalize kinetic energy between the two interacting entities, tending to increase the velocity of the less-massive component. In trinary systems formed by symmetrical FFF, orbital interplay progressively transfers kinetic energy from the massive twin components to the diminutive companion component, progressively ‘evaporating’ it into a circumbinary orbit around the twin components, that sink inward to form a binary pair, conserving system energy and angular momentum. Equipartition of kinetic energy converts a dynamically unstable, nonhierarchical system formed by symmetrical FFF into a stable, hierarchical circumbinary system.
    Once the tertiary companion has been pushed far enough outward that the system becomes hierarchical, large energy exchanges with the central twin binary shut down. What remains can be continued angular-momentum exchange, changing eccentricities and inclinations in Lidov–Kozai cycles, but largely without energy exchange between the twin binary and the companion. So, for solitary stars with brown dwarf companions to have formed by symmetrical FFF, the spiral-in merger of the twin binary pair presumably requires extensive interaction with the remaining disk gas or continuing infall from the envelope, which interacts gravitationally and hydrodynamically with the central twin binary. In our own solar system, the prestellar grains incorporated into chondrites may indicate continuing infall from our residual disk or natal envelope for several million years after the binary spiral-in merger of our former Binary-Sun. Our own solar system presumably formed by symmetrical FFF of the primary accretion disk, followed by 4 generations of trifurcation (§ 4), followed by the spiral-in merger of Binary-Sun in a luminous red nova (LRN) at 4,567 Ma, spawning the asteroid belt (§ 7). The Alpha Centauri system is presumably the result of symmetrical FFF of its pseudodisk, and the 90–150 M🜨 candidate planet, Alpha Centauri Ab, orbiting Alpha Centauri A may be an asymmetrical FFF planet formed from the fragmentation of a secondary accretion disk formed around the A component. So, the Alpha Centauri A candidate planet is a test case for the possibility of asymmetrical FFF in secondary accretion disks formed around the twin components of symmetrical FFF.
    A small number of the most-massive cold Jupiters around solitary stars may have formed by symmetrical FFF, although brown-dwarf-mass and larger red dwarf stars would be much more capable of perturbing their twin stars to spiral in and merge.
    Contact-binary SSSBs and wide-binary KBOs with similar size and color components, may indicate that symmetrical FFF is the typical outcome of streaming instability. The Pluto system is amenable to a symmetrical FFF origin, with Pluto and Charon as twin components. Then the former central core of the Pluto system may have undergone 2 generations of trifurcation, with Nix-Hydra as 1st-generation trifurcation twins and Styx-Kerberos as 2nd-generation twins (§ 4).
    The percentage of stellar binaries increases with stellar mass, which may in part indicate increasing rates of symmetrical FFF with mass, and, perhaps, decreasing capacity of tertiary companions to cause binary spiral-in mergers. Distant companions, like Proxima Centauri, are very difficult to find and may be missed in short-duration surveys for multiple star systems. Finally, more-massive twin stars may more effectively eject companions, and companions in high orbits may be lost by close encounters with sister stars in the close confines of stellar nurseries.

Brown Dwarfs:
    Brown dwarfs slot between giant planets and stars in mass, ranging from 13–80 Mj. The lower 13 Mj limit is the threshold for deuterium burning, and the upper 80 Mj limit is the threshold for hydrogen burning, so brown dwarfs are defined by their ability to fuse deuterium and their inability to fuse hydrogen. This fusion-based definition may not fit well with their formation mechanism, however. Indeed, brown dwarfs appear to constitute a bimodal population, with a 30–55 Mj scarcity in between.
The occurrence rate of BDs follows a power law on both sides of the scarcity region (Grether & Lineweaver 2006). Notably, the scarcity is most prominent within the 30–55 MJup range (Ma & Ge 2014; Holl et al. 2022), with approximately half of the BD population on each side. The two populations of BDs barely overlap, suggesting that they originate from different formation mechanisms (Chabrier et al. 2014; Ma & Ge 2014; Whitworth 2018). (Unger et al., 2023)
Ma & Ge (2014) suggested that BDs lighter than 42.5 Mj form through disc instability like planets, while heavier companions form like stellar binaries by cloud fragmentation. This represents a bimodal origin within the standard model. In this regard, it’s more than a little surprising that there is not also an orbital-period divide between the two populations, requiring that brown dwarfs formed by disk instability and by cloud fragmentation result in no angular momentum disparity.
    The working hypothesis within the FFF architecture for this bimodal population extends the m = 1 spiral-density-wave asymmetrical FFF paradigm to m= 2 spiral-density-wave symmetrical FFF, attributing the low-mass population to accretion disk fragmentation and the high-mass population to pesudodisk fragmentation. Thus, 55–13 Mj brown dwarfs and likely some high-mass giant planets presumably form by symmetrical FFF of primary accretion disks. And 55–80 Mj brown dwarfs and some low-mass red dwarfs presumably form by symmetrical FFF of pseudodisks. Symmetrical FFF is presumably the final system-wide FFF event of stellar systems, although subsystem fragmentation of secondary accretion disks formed around the twin components may be commonplace, as in Alpha Centauri Ab. Because diminutive tertiary components evolved from protostellar cores in symmetrical FFF may span the range from high planetary mass to lower stellar mass, the term ‘companion’ will be used as a convenient moniker, not to be confused with former Binary-Companion in our solar system.
   As noted above, the stark mass difference between brown-dwarf symmetrical FFF products and giant-planet asymmetrical FFF products is presumably due to protostellar cores retaining a portion of their accretion disks following symmetrical FFF, resulting in continuing protostellar-core accretion beyond the twin fragmentation event itself. And in symmetrical FFF of pseudodisks, protostellar cores retain a larger portion of their accretion disks than in symmetrical FFF of (primary) accretion disks. Our solar system is understood to have formed with a symmetrical FFF companion in the low brown dwarf mass range, below the 30–55 Mj scarcity valley, and therefore presumably formed by primary accretion disk fragmentation. By comparison, the companion of the Alpha Centauri system, Proxima Centauri, is a 0.122 M☉ red dwarf star in a stellar system twice the mass of the Sun, pointing to pseudodisk fragmentation far above the 30–55 Mj scarcity valley. Curiously, the bimodality in asymmetrical FFF is in orbital period, whereas the bimodality in symmetrical FFF is in mass, but the comparison between the two classes is not straight forward, if hot Jupiters are formed in a two-stage process from secondary accretion disks and if symmetrical FFF systems are subject to orbital interplay. Additionally, both symmetrical and asymmetrical systems are subject to continuing infall from the natal envelope, which presumably manifests itself differently in the two classes.
   The brown-dwarf desert inside 5 AU (Wilson et al. 2016) indicates that the end products of symmetrical FFF capture more of the system angular momentum than the end products of asymmetrical FFF, in the form of greater mass at a greater average lever arm. The diminutive size of giant planet cores in asymmetrical FFF systems requires that a substantial fraction of the system angular momentum is carried away by escaping gas that necessarily acquires greater specific angular momentum in the fragmentation event than the specific angular momentum of the natal Jeans instability, whereas symmetrical FFF does not have this requirement at formation, but the spiral-in merger of the twin components appears to require continuing infall to carry off the twin binary angular momentum.
   If many twin stars and almost all brown dwarfs in star systems form by symmetrical FFF, then it seems strange that circumbinary brown dwarfs are not the rule in binary star systems, although most brown dwarfs may have been ejected or on such eccentric orbits that they haven’t been found. Indeed, the definitive confirmation that Proxima Centauri belongs to the Alpha Centauri system did not occur until 2017.
   Binary brown dwarfs may also form by symmetrical FFF, with brown dwarfs as the twin components. This suggests a much-smaller circumbinary companion or former companion, presumably in the planetary mass range.

(Mini-)Neptunes and the sub-Saturn desert:
    This working hypothesis attempts to explain a sub-Saturn desert alongside the relative abundance of Neptune-mass planets and smaller gaseous mini-Neptunes, collectively “(mini)-Neptunes”, specifically the type of (mini-)Neptunes that presumably formed like hot Jupiters in a two-planet architecture. Another class of mini-Neptunes, not discussed here, may have formed by hybrid accretion like super-Earths, which became sufficiently massive to accrete some hydrogen and helium. And mini-Neptunes formed by hybrid accretion would tend to be found in super-Earth chains, like peas in a pod.
    Chen et al., (2026) find a strong correlation between single-transiting short-period sub-Neptunes with an outer Cold Jupiter companion, which suggests formation by secondary-accretion-disk fragmentation like hot Jupiters. And mini-Neptunes are the most prevalent planet type discovered.
    Additionally, Bertaux & Ivanova (2022) “confirm the existence of a sub-Saturn desert (at least for periods < 100 d), most depleted […] in the range 0.1–0.2 Mjup (~32-64 M⊕)”.
    Combining these two findings suggests the possibility that some (mini-)Neptunes may have formed as sub-Saturn-mass protostellar cores, which lost the bulk of their pithy gaseous components in the cataclysm of disk fragmentation. This possibly caused some sub-Saturn-mass protostellar cores to dissipate into (mini-)Neptunes, with rocky cores that retained sufficient hydrogen and helium to remain gaseous planets. Interstellar gas experiences a degree of pressure support during Jeans instability freefall, such that dust and ice grains have a higher terminal velocity than gas in the freefall of a Jeans instability. And a higher terminal velocity may cause dust and ice to accumulate disproportionately at the center of accreting protostellar cores, forming rocky-icy inner cores in gaseous protostellar cores prior to the FHSC phase. Additionally, the progressively increasing gas density with decreasing radial distance within protostellar cores elevates the partial pressure of gaseous metallicity, promoting volatile condensation onto dust grains in freefall, contributing volatile ice to the refractory dust in the inner core. And the rocky-icy inner core provides assurance against complete disruption in the cataclysm of disk fragmentation.
    The vertical black arrows in Fig. 2 indicate the suggested sub-Saturn-mass origin of some of the (mini-)Neptunes in the 10–100 d orbital period valley prior to losing the bulk of their gaseous component. The verticality of the arrows assumes that dissipation only affected their mass, not their orbital periods, which may not be a sound assumption but which serves as a starting point for a working hypothesis. This secondary process could indicate that sub-Saturns are not as formationally scarce as they are observationally scarce.
    If sub-Saturn-mass planets indeed formed by secondary accretion disk fragmentation as the low-mass end of the hot Jupiter population, then they would presumably represent an extension of the negative slope of the hot Jupiter clump into the 10–100 d giant-planet orbital period valley. This suggests that gaseous dissipation of sub-Saturn-mass planets formed by FFF may be responsible for the short period end of the 10–100 d giant-planet orbital period valley.

L1448 IRS3B (Fig. 1):
    The triple star system L1448 IRS3B presumably formed by symmetrical FFF, where the diminutive companion outshines its much-more-massive twin siblings, due to the older, more advanced development of the former protostellar core. This triple star system is composed of a similar-sized binary pair, IRS3B-a & IRS3B-b, with a combined mass of ~1 M☉ in a 61 AU binary orbit, and a distant tertiary companion, IRS3B-c, with a minimum mass of ~0.085 M☉, in a 183 AU circumbinary orbit around the binary pair. This system may become more hierarchical over time, coming to resemble the Alpha Centauri system at half the mass.
“Thus, we expect the [L1448 IRS3B] orbits to evolve on rapid timescales (with respect to the expected stellar lifetime), especially as the disk dissipates. A natural outcome of this dynamical instability is the formation of a more hierarchical system with a tighter (few AU) inner pair and wider (100s to 1,000s AU) tertiary, consistent with observed triple systems.” (Tobin et al. 2016)
    The tertiary companion, IRS3B-c, is embedded in a spiral arm of the outer disk, which has an estimated mass of 0.3 M☉. The standard model of companion star formation, expressed in the Tobin paper, suggests that IRS3B-c formed in situ by gravitational instability from the spiral disk, presumably making IRS3B-c younger than IRS3B-a & IRS3B-b; however, IRS3B-c is brighter at 1.3 mm and 8 mm than its much more massive siblings, which is apparent in Fig. 1. The more luminous tertiary companion supports formation by symmetrical FFF, with the diminutive companion as the more-evolved former protostellar core of the system, presumably formed by pseudodisk fragmentation, similar to the Alpha Centauri system but with half the mass.
………………..

4. Trifurcation by centrifugal fragmentation


    This study proposes a rare planet formation mechanism for the three sets of twin planets (Jupiter–Saturn, Uranus–Neptune, and Venus–Earth plus Mercury) in our highly unusual solar system. This novel planet formation mechanism can form twin planets in descending sizes like Russian nesting dolls by successive episodes of centrifugal fragmentation in a process designated ‘trifurcation’.
Trifurcation requires three specific conditions:
1. A non-axisymmetric, gravitationally bound object;
2. Which has undergone internal differentiation (forming an iron inner core);
3. Within a nonhierarchical trinary (or higher-order) system undergoing chaotic orbital interplay.

Rotational spin up:
    During rotational spin up, a planemo-scale object—one massive enough to attain a spherical shape via self-gravity—will first become an oblate Maclaurin spheroid.  Continued spin-up eventually reaches a critical threshold known as the bifurcation point, where the Maclaurin sequence intersects with another family of equilibrium shapes: the Jacobi ellipsoids. A rotating fluid body always adopts the configuration that minimizes its total energy (kinetic plus potential) for a fixed angular momentum. Beyond the bifurcation point, an elongated, triaxial shape possesses lower total energy than a highly flattened disk. This satisfies the non-axisymmetric requirement for a planemo-scale object behaving as a fluid body.
    Critically, ultra-fast rotation is a baseline theoretical expectation for protostars, giving rise to the so-called “angular momentum problem” in stellar astrophysics—namely, how they shed excess rotation to sustain collapse. Thus, it is plausible that a protostar could be born as a triaxial Jacobi ellipsoid, meeting the first prerequisite for trifurcation.

Internally differentiated into an iron inner core:
    Standard computer modeling of centrifugal fission characteristically yields bifurcation (two bodies), not trifurcation (three bodies). However, internal differentiation—with discrete density steps between atmosphere, crust, mantle, and core—may fundamentally alter the outcome. In a rotationally induced Jacobi ellipsoid, buoyancy preferentially drives low-density outer layers into the triaxial geometry’s outer arms. Continuing spin up drives the Jacobi ellipsoid into a bar-mode instability, at which point self-gravity can fragment the arms. In a homogeneous body, this produces two components (bifurcation). In a differentiated body, however, this study suggests that the dense central core survives while the lower-density arms fragment into twin components, yielding a total of three bodies—hence, trifurcation.

Spin-up during chaotic orbital interplay:
    Stellar systems can be born nonhierarchical, with components engaged in chaotic orbital interplay. Through equipartition of kinetic energy during hyperbolic close encounters, the more massive components sink inward while less massive ones are progressively ‘evaporated’ outward. Consider a trinary system composed of a twin stellar pair and a diminutive brown dwarf-mass protostar: the brown dwarf is progressively ejected into a circumbinary orbit, while the twin pair sinks inward to form a central binary. Crucially, if the brown dwarf-mass protostar is born as a Jacobi ellipsoid, its triaxial geometry provides substantial “handles” for tidal interactions with its larger siblings.
    The relevant tidal mechanics operate as follows: super-synchronous rotation (where an object rotates faster than its orbital period) raises a leading tidal bulge, which is pulled backward by the host body, progressively slowing its rotation. Conversely, sub-synchronous rotation raises a lagging tide, speeding up the object’s rotation. Achieving sub-synchronous rotation at periapsis for a brown dwarf spun into a Jacobi ellipsoid would require an extreme, near-star-grazing encounter. However, triaxial objects can tumble chaotically in addition to rotating around their principal spin axis, and the quadrupole gravitational moment of a triaxial body offers many possible tidal configurations beyond principal-axis rotation.
    Therefore, even if the object is super-synchronous at periapsis, sub-synchronous rotation with respect to other axes can induce lagging tides that excite non-principal-axis rotation—i.e., chaotic tumbling—when the principal spin axis is tilted relative to the orbital axis. As the diminutive component recedes from periapsis, it may be left in a state of high-energy chaotic tumbling. The instability of this tumbling causes internal fluid friction, damping the wobble over time, while conservation of angular momentum may simultaneously spin up the primary axis.
    When a rapidly rotating, differentiated body spins up to the bar-mode instability threshold, the resulting elongated bar retains its densest material at the center of mass. Nevertheless, the extended, lower-density arms can accumulate sufficient mass to become self-gravitating in their own right, competing with the central gravitational attractor. Once a local attractor’s pull exceeds that of the core, a new center of gravity forms and pinches off into a separate Roche sphere. The bar transforms into twin Roche spheres in bifurcation, but when the body is internally differentiated, this study proposes that a residual third Roche sphere remains at the former center of gravity, resulting in trifurcation.

Trifurcation dynamics:
    The following scenario requires that our former protostellar disk was much more massive than the central brown-dwarf-mass protostar, designated ‘Brown Dwarf’, and consequently developed a dominant m = 2 spiral density wave. The massive protostellar disk gravitationally fragmented to form a twin stellar pair, which along with Brown Dwarf constituted a trinary system. Brown Dwarf was presumably born with ultra-fast rotation as a Jacobi ellipsoid with a triaxial geometry that was susceptible to spin up in orbital close encounters with the twin stellar components. And the twin stellar components became our former binary-Sun. § 3
    ‘Brown Dwarf’ spun up into a bar-mode instability which underwent trifurcation, forming a twin pair of super-Jupiter-mass components in an unstable nonhierarchical orbit around a diminutive core remaining at the center of rotation designated ‘Super-Jupiter’. (Note: the twin pair was much more massive than the residual core, Super-Jupiter, despite all three components being in the super-Jupiter-mass range.) And Super-Jupiter was similarly born with ultra-fast rotation as a Jacobi ellipsoid with triaxial geometry. Thus, the first-generation trifurcation products were a smaller version of the original trinary star system, and due to symmetry, first-generation trifurcation promotes next-generation trifurcation and so on, potentially forming multiple sets of twin planets in diminishing sizes like Russian nesting dolls.

    Our solar system presumably formed by symmetrical FFF followed by 4 generations of trifurcation, which created 1 + 4 = 5 sets of binary pairs (Binary-Sun, Binary-Companion, Jupiter–Saturn, Uranus–Neptune, and Venus–Earth) plus Mercury, the residual core of the 4th-generation trifurcation:
– Symmetrical FFF of circumstellar disk around a brown dwarf-mass protostar, yielded twin nascent stars (Binary-Sun) + Brown Dwarf (protostar)
– 1st-gen. trifurcation of Brown Dwarf (protostar) by Binary-Sun yielded Binary-Companion + SUPER-Jupiter (residual core)
– 2nd-gen. trifurcation of SUPER-Jupiter by Binary-Companion yielded Jupiter–Saturn + SUPER-Neptune (residual core)
– 3rd-gen. trifurcation of SUPER-Neptune by Jupiter–Saturn yielded Uranus–Neptune + SUPER-Earth (residual core)
– 4th-gen. trifurcation of SUPER-Earth by Uranus–Neptune yielded Venus–Earth + Mercury (residual core)
(Note: unorthodox capitalization indicates unorthodox definitions for transitory objects: ‘SUPER-Jupiter’, ‘SUPER-Neptune’ and ‘SUPER-Earth’ are proper names for the former residual cores formed in the first three trifurcation generations. And Mars formed by an alternative planet formation mechanism § 2.)

Trifurcation debris disk:
   Trifurcation is presumably a messy process, such that 4 generations of trifurcation created a massive ‘trifurcation debris disk’, which was shaped by the dynamic unwinding of the trifurcation subsystems. The debris disk had an outer ring in Neptune’s outer resonances and may have had an inner ring in Jupiter’s inner resonances, corresponding the the present asteroid belt. The debris disk was siderophile depleted, because the trifurcation planets were internally differentiated, which largely sequestered their iron-nickel cores from evaporation during the trifurcation process. Additionally, the seven trifurcation planets and the trifurcation debris disk lay on the well-mixed three-oxygen-isotope Brown Dwarf fractionation line, which we know as the terrestrial fractionation line (TFL).  The outer ring of the trifurcation debris disk spawned the hot classical KBOs and an inner debris ring may have similarly spawned small Solar System bodies comparable to the asteroids, but these presumably in the luminous red nova created when the stellar components of former Binary-Sun spiraled in and merged at 4,567 Ma, which enveloped the entire inner solar system and perhaps part of the outer solar system as well.

Dynamic evolution by resonance chasing:
    Following the epoch of trifurcation, the 5 sets of twin binary pairs plus twin binary pairs in circumbinary orbits around parental binary pairs created a multiplicity of ‘heartbeats’ in our early Solar System, which were susceptible to resonance chasing. Resonance chasing can cause a local decrease in entropy as long as it creates an overall increase in entropy, expressed in the spiral in of our former Binary-Sun. The unwinding of symmetrical FFF, followed by four generations of trifurcation into our present Solar System configuration, required at least two types of resonance chasing: one causing twin binary pairs to spiral out of their parental twin binary pair’s gravity wells, and another causing binary pairs to separate into solitary planets.
    It appears that the trifurcation generations did not unwind in a hierarchical fashion. The present-day configuration of the solar system can best be explained by Jupiter–Saturn gravitationally capturing Venus–Earth–Mercury from Uranus–Neptune followed by Binary-Companion capturing Uranus–Neptune from Jupiter–Saturn. Then Binary-Sun captured Uranus–Neptune via Binary-Companion’s far-side L2 Lagrange point and Binary-Sun captured Jupiter–Saturn, with Venus–Earth–Mercury in tow via Binary-Companion’s near-side L1 Lagrange point. Finally, Binary-Sun captured Venus–Earth–Mercury from Jupiter–Saturn via Jupiter–Saturn’s near-side L1 Lagrange point.
    With all orbits being prograde, capture of Uranus–Neptune by Binary-Sun from Binary-Companion at its L2 Lagrange point resulted in a prograde kick to Uranus–Neptune, since the former Uranus–Neptune orbit around Binary-Companion was in the same instantaneous-linear-velocity direction as its new heliocentric orbit at Binary-Companion’s L2 Lagrange point. By comparison, Jupiter–Saturn, with Venus–Earth–Mercury in tow, received a retrograde kick at Binary-Companion’s L1 Lagrange point, since the former Jupiter–Saturn orbit around Binary-Companion was exactly opposed in instantaneous linear velocity to its new heliocentric orbit at the L1 point of capture. Thus, the velocity vectors add at the L2 Lagrange point, resulting in a prograde kick in the new heliocentric orbit, whereas the velocity vectors subtract at the L1 Lagrange point, resulting in a retrograde kick in the new heliocentric orbit. And similarly, Venus–Earth–Mercury must have been captured at Jupiter–Saturn L1 Lagrange point and Mercury at the Venus–Earth L1 Lagrange point. All this presupposes a particularly planar Solar System.
    A similar thing happened when the binary planets spiraled out from their binary barycenters to be captured into solitary heliocentric orbits, where the planet further from the Sun, at the binary L2 Lagrange point, received a prograde kick, while its binary companion at the L1 Lagrange point received a retrograde kick. These prograde and retrograde kicks created sufficient separation between formerly associated planets to create the relative stability of our evolved Solar System.

Pluto system:
    Binary asteroids and Kuiper belt objects (KBOs) presumably also formed by symmetrical FFF during streaming instability, and some may have undergone bifurcation or trifurcation as well. The Pluto system has 4 small moons that could be characterized as two sets of twin binary pairs in descending size from two trifurcation generations of a former differentiated core formed at the center of rotation of the streaming instability. Thus, Pluto-Charon would be the symmetrical FFF twins, with Nix–Hydra (50 × 35 × 33 km)–(65 × 45 × 25 km) as 1st–generation trifurcation twins, and Styx–Kerbos (16 × 9 × 8 km)–(19 × 10 × 9 km) as 2nd-generation twins, although the second generation centrifugal fission event could have been bifurcation rather than trifurcation. First-generation trifurcation required a differentiated body, which could have formed by ‘aqueous differentiation’, the melting of water ice to form a sedimentary silicate core surrounded by a saltwater ocean with an icy crust. And the elongated shapes of the 4 small moons may be evidence for centrifugal fission of cores elongated by rotation into triaxial geometries.
    Trifurcation has the testable requirement that the trifurcation twins, Nix and Hydra, must be composed of lower denser material than the next-generation twins, Styx and Kerberos. Indeed, the 1.0 ± 0.2 g cm−3 density for Nix and the 1.2 ± 0.2 g cm−3 density for Hydra are consistent with mostly water ice, although the most that can be said for the densities of Styx and Kerberos is that they are both <2.1 g cm−3. (Porter and Canup 2023)
………………..

5. Trifurcation Moons


    The extreme isotopic similarity between Earth and Moon points to a common origin from the Brown Dwarf reservoir by way of trifurcation. But the Moon cannot be the residual core of the 4th-generation trifurcation because its iron core is disproportionately small compared to Earth’s iron core. Instead, spiral tails emanating from the ends of the bar in dynamical bar-mode instabilities suggest an origin mechanism for forming ‘trifurcation moons’. In computer simulations, dynamical bar-mode instabilities intermittently exhibit spiral tails, trailing from the 2 ends of the central bar in dynamical bar-mode instabilities, similar to the spiral arms that trail from the central bar in barred spiral galaxies. And when these tails become detached from the central bar due to trifurcation of the bar, they may gravitationally coalesce into their own Roche spheres to form trifurcation moons. Prior to trifurcation, the spiral tails are physically attached to the bar, and after trifurcation the nascent trifurcation moons remain gravitationally bound to their respective nascent twin-binary siblings. By this mechanism, Venus and Earth would have each acquired a gravitationally bound trifurcation moon in the 4th-generation trifurcation.
    In a dynamical bar-mode instability, the bar rotates like a solid object, governed by the specific kinetic energy of the system and the self-gravity of the bar. Solid rotation causes the ends of the bar to rotate at super-Keplerian speed, which may cause material to slough off into twin swept-back tails that rise into slightly higher Keplerian or near Keplerian orbits, which is what appears to happen in this computer simulation.

    So, the rotational spin up of a prestellar/protostellar core following symmetrical FFF may cause centrifugal fragmentation of the core into 5 components, where the bar trifurcates into a twin pair of trifurcation planets plus a planetary-mass residual core, and where the spiral arms gravitationally pinch off into a pair of trifurcation moons. So if spin up centrifugal fragmentation of protostellar cores and residual cores indeed form 5 objects, then a more fitting term would be ‘quintifurcation’, which is sufficiently awkward that ‘trifurcation+2’ will suffice when including twin trifurcation moons. And trifurcation+2 occurs in higher-generation trifurcations as well as in the original symmetrical FFF.

    Trifurcation moons are born with no net angular momentum with respect to their respective their respective twin-binary siblings, but the first kick from the host binary pair that induced trifurcation+2 apparently injects one trifurcation moon into a prograde orbit around its respective twin planet, while symmetrically injecting its twin trifurcation moon in a retrograde orbit around its respective twin planet. Thus, since Luna acquired a prograde orbit around Earth, we presume that by symmetry, Venus acquired a corresponding trifurcation moon in a retrograde orbit, which was doomed to decay and ultimately merge with the planet.

Jupiter-Saturn:
    If Titan is Saturn’s prograde trifurcation moon, then Jupiter presumably had a retrograde trifurcation moon that has long since merged with the planet, possibly at 4,562 Ma, forming enstatite chondrites that lie on the 3-oxygen isotope ‘terrestrial fractionation line’, with the moony merger explosion possibly melting water ice in nearby CI chondrites, forming dolomites in internal fissures.

Uranus-Neptune:
    The retrograde orbit of Triton at Neptune presupposes a former prograde trifurcation moon at Uranus, which was presumably lost when Binary-Companion’s progressively increasing eccentricity overran Uranus, stripping Uranus of its moons and causing its 98° axial tilt. If any of Uranus’ moons merged with Binary-Companion they would have fogged the solar system and contributed to the Sturtian glaciation of the Cryogenian period. Triton’s retrograde orbit will ultimately spiral in to merge with Neptune in about 3.6 billion years, which may cause another glaciation on Earth.

Venus-Earth:
    The prograde orbit of Earth’s Moon, Luna, presupposes a former retrograde trifurcation moon around Venus, which may have spiraled in and merged with Venus at 579 Ma, fogging the inner solar system, causing the Gaskiers glaciation on Earth (§ 8).

Trifurcation moon summary:
– Jupiter: former retrograde trifurcation moon that may have merged with the planet at 4,562 Ma
– Saturn: prograde trifurcation moon Titan
– Uranus: lost prograde trifurcation moon
– Neptune: retrograde trifurcation moon, Triton
– Venus: former retrograde trifurcation moon that may have merged with the planet at 579 Ma
– Earth: prograde trifurcation moon, Luna

    Earth’s oversized Moon is much larger in proportion to Earth than Titan is to Saturn, which may be expected, since a rocky planetary core must achieve a mass of 5–10 M⊕ before it can hold onto hydrogen and helium. The 1st-generation residual core, SUPER-Jupiter, was overwhelmingly composed of volatile hydrogen and helium, and since the spiral arms represent an additional fractionation, the gravitational collapse of the rocky and icy components was only able to form a moon the size of Titan.
    The rocky residual core of the 4th-generation trifurcation, SUPER-Earth, had essentially no hydrogen and helium envelope, such that the spiral arms trailing from the outer ends of the central bar were nearly gas free, resulting in a proportionally-more-massive trifurcation moon at Earth compared to Saturn. But the fractionation of the spiral arm trailing from the bar end that became Earth explains the proportionally smaller iron core of the Moon compared to Earth. The size of the Lunar core is only about 20% of the volume of the Moon, in contrast to about 50% for Earth and Venus.
………………..

6. Former Binary-Companion


    This study suggests that former Binary-Companion was the twin pair from the first-generation trifurcation of the protostellar core of our solar system, designated Brown Dwarf. In this clockwork scenario, our solar system formed by symmetrical FFF, in which a lopsided accretion disk (bar-mode instability) fragmented to form twin disk fragmentation objects that became our former Binary-Sun, which induced the spin-up fragmentation (trifurcation) of Brown Dwarf to form the twin super-Jupiter-mass components of Binary-Companion.

    The mass of former Brown Dwarf and former Binary-Companion may someday be estimated if enough extra-solar-system examples of planetary systems formed by trifurcation can be identified, and the reason for the scarcity of trifurcation planets in stellar systems formed by symmetrical FFF (such as Alpha Centauri) may be deduced.
    For planetary trifurcation, we only have one residual core for examination, that of Mercury; however, Mercury and the other terrestrial planets were presumably eroded by solar plasma during their brief immersion in the luminous red nova (LRN) phase of the merged Sun at 4,567 Ma, with Venus more deeply immersed than Earth, and Mercury more deeply immersed than Venus. Plasma immersion presumably stripped away atmospheres and oceans and likely boiled off an indeterminate quantity of crustal material as well. Some studies indicate that Venus has a similar-size iron core as Earth in a planet with only 81.5% of Earth’s mass, which could be indicative of the differential mass loss between Earth and Venus, and if so, then Mercury lost a still greater percentage. So, the 4th generation trifurcation is presumably tainted by LRN immersion, but even without an LRN, there would be a sharp distinction between terrestrial planets and gaseous planets capable of retaining hydrogen and helium, with a cutoff from core accretion theory of about 5 M⊕.
    Uranus and Neptune are able to retain hydrogen and helium, and thus wouldn’t have automatically lost a volatile inheritance from trifurcation. Additionally, their semimajor axes put them beyond or at least far out in the LRN envelopment, presumably with much less effect than that experienced by the terrestrial planets.
    Unlike the smaller trifurcation twins, Jupiter and Saturn have a large mass disparity. While Jupiter and Saturn are more likely to have gained than lost mass by LRN immersion, and Jupiter more than Saturn because of deeper immersion and deeper gravity well, the brief, circa 1 month duration of the envelopment should have had a minor effect on their overall mass, so the mass disparity is most likely an aspect of trifurcation. While there are no other exoplanetary systems suspected to have formed by trifurcation for comparison, there should be enough trinary star systems formed by symmetrical FFF from bar-mode instability precursors, similar to the bar-mode instabilities in trifurcation, to assess the relative mass disparity of twin components formed by fragmenting bar-mode instabilities. In the trinary Alpha Centauri system, presumably formed by symmetrical FFF, the twin components are quite similar in mass, with α Centauri A having a mass of 1.079 M⊙, and α Centauri B having a mass of 0.909 M⊙.

Relative mass progression between trifurcation generations:
(mU + mN) / (mV + m⊕) = 31.69 m⊕ / 1.815 m⊕ = 17.46
(mJ + mS) / (mU + mN) = 412.96 m⊕ / 31.69 m⊕ = 13.03
mBC / (mJ + mS) = ?

Binary-Companion and Brown Dwarf mass:
    A mass regression between the 1st and 2nd generation twin binary pairs equal to that of the regression between the 2nd and 3rd generation twin binary pairs may have imbued former Binary-Companion with a mass of 13 * 413 m⊕ = 5,369 m⊕ * 1 mJ / 318 m⊕ = 16.6 mJ, where even a 3:1 mass disparity between the twin components of Binary-Companion, like the mass disparity between Jupiter and Saturn, would most-likely keep both of the twin binary components of former Binary-Companion below the brown dwarf threshold.
    The mass loss due to each trifurcation generation is unknown, but it was apparently sufficient to form hot classical KBOs. All that can be said for the mass of Brown Dwarf is that it was greater than that of all the other planets combined, Binary-Companion included, Mars excluded.

Why the twin components of each trifurcation generation remained paired:
    The configuration of our solar system with twin-binary planets in adjacent heliocentric orbits suggests that twin-binary pairs were captured by Binary-Sun from Binary-Companion as binary pairs, before the twin pairs spiraled out and separated. Jupiter-Saturn were apparently captured by Binary-Sun via the near-side L1 Lagrange point of Binary-Companion, while Venus-Earth-Mercury were still embedded in the Jupiter-Saturn gravity well. By contrast, Uranus-Neptune were presumably captured by Binary-Sun via the far-side L2 Lagrange point. This arrangement placed Binary-Companion in a heliocentric orbit between present day Saturn and Uranus.
    Gravitational capture via the L1 Lagrange point caused Jupiter-Saturn, with the terrestrial planets in tow, to fall into a heliocentric orbit much below the L1 Lagrange point of Binary-Companion. At the L1 Lagrange point, the velocity of the prograde orbit (CCW) of Jupiter-Saturn around Binary-Companion was 180° opposed to the velocity of the prograde heliocentric orbit (CCW) of Binary-Companion around Binary-Sun, such that the kinetic energy of the two orbits subtracted. Thus, Jupiter-Saturn, with the terrestrial planets in tow, received a retrograde kick when captured by Binary-Sun and fell into a heliocentric orbit much below the L1 Lagrange point of Binary-Companion.
    The opposite effect happened to Uranus-Neptune at the L2 Lagrange point of Binary-Companion, where the velocity of the prograde orbit of Uranus-Neptune around

inary-Companion was in the same direction as the velocity of the heliocentric orbit, such that the kinetic energy around binary-Companion added to the heliocentric kinetic energy, giving Uranus-Neptune a prograde kick into a much-higher heliocentric orbit than the L2 Lagrange point.

Resonance chasing § 4:
    Gravitational interactions in the form of resonance chasing drives orbits toward mean motion resonances (MMRs). But resonance chasing can only proceed in the thermodynamically favored direction, which corresponds to an inward projection of mass that causes the spiral in of relatively more-massive components and the spiral out of relatively less-massive components, which can entail the spiraling in/out of both twin-binary components and twin-binary pairs. Thus, resonance chasing between Uranus-Neptune and Binary-Companion caused Uranus and Neptune to spiral out from their binary barycenter and also caused the twin-binary pair (Uranus-Neptune) to spiral away from Binary-Companion until being captured by Binary-Sun at binary-Companion’s L2 Lagrange point, and the energy and angular momentum driving the spiral out of Uranus and Neptune came from the spiral in of the super-Jupiter-mass components of binary-Companion, resulting in an overall inward projection of mass. The continual/continuous spiral in/out inherent in resonance chasing during the unwinding of multiple trifurcation generations creates only temporary MMRs that quickly fade, necessitating the chasing of the next upcoming MMR in the thermodynamically-favored direction. In this manner, binary-Companion cleared its Hill sphere of trifurcation planets presumably prior to the binary spiral in merger of binary-Sun at 4,567 Ma.

Secular evolution of Binary-Companion and the LHB:
    In a prograde-coplanar system with a binary planet orbiting its star, secular energy transfer from a binary’s internal orbit to the heliocentric orbit can occur through gravitational interactions mediated by quadrupole perturbations. The gravitational potential of a binary planet includes a time-varying quadrupole moment, due to its orbital motion. This quadrupole moment perturbs the central star and vice versa, enabling energy and angular momentum exchange. The binary’s orbital motion creates an asymmetric gravitational potential, approximated by its quadrupole moment, which varies periodically at twice the binary’s orbital frequency, causing a ‘heartbeat’ effect. The quadrupole potential at the Sun is given by Eq. 1, which is proportional to the square of the semimajor axis of the internal binary components “a” divided by the cube of the heliocentric semimajor axis “r”. The binary’s quadrupole moment varies as the components orbit the binary barycenter, creating a time-varying gravitational field at the Sun, leading to the exchange of energy and angular momentum between the binary and heliocentric orbits of Binary-Companion. The exact mathematical treatment would involve expanding the gravitational potential to the quadrupole order, deriving the equations of motion for the orbital elements, and solving the secular equations to find the long-term evolution.
    Secular evolution due to the binary quadrupole may operate by several mechanisms:
– Secular tidal torques: The binary’s quadrupole creates tidal bulges on the central star. A phase lag in the star’s response (due to internal dissipation or dynamical delays) generates a torque.
– Three-Body Secular Resonance: The binary’s orbital precession (driven by the star’s quadrupole) couples with the heliocentric orbit’s precession, creating a resonant exchange.
– Eccentricity Pumping via Quadrupole Coupling: The binary’s quadrupole induces periodic perturbations on the star, driving slow oscillations in the heliocentric orbit’s eccentricity.
    In addition to the quadrupole moment inherent in binary orbits, a highly-oblate early Sun would have had a significant quadrupole moment of its own. The newly merged Sun would have had a rapid rotation rate, which may have transiently adopted a triaxial Jacobi ellipsoid shape after its binary spiral-in merger at 4,567 Ma, but even after settling into an axisymmetric Maclaurin spheroid, its early rapid rotation rate would have resulted in a significantly-oblate spheroid with a comparably-significant gravitational quadrupole moment of its own, which directly perturbed Binary-Companion. The Sun’s quadrupole moment could have caused apsidal precession in the binary’s internal orbit, altering its orientation. And precession modifies the binary’s quadrupole orientation, which in turn could have affected the heliocentric orbit’s evolution. Additionally, the combined gravitational potential includes cross terms from both quadrupoles:
Φtotal ∝ ΦSun + Φbinary + ΦSun-binary
​The cross term (interaction term) ΦSun-binary arises from the product of the stellar and binary quadrupole moments. These terms are nonlinear and can dominate in regimes where both quadrupoles are significant.
    But if abinary/aheliocentric ≳ 0.1, then chaotic three-body interactions may have dominated over the secular effects described above.
    Regardless of cause, the spiral-in of Binary-Companion would have progressively increased the eccentricity and semimajor axis of the heliocentric orbit over time. Orbital energy is inversely proportional to the semimajor axis alone (E ∝ -1/a), but angular momentum is proportional to the square root of the semimajor axis times (1 – e²), so angular momentum is a function of semimajor axis and eccentricity (L ∝ √(a(1 – e²))). Since E scales with 1/a and L with √a, the ratio E/L scales as 1/(a * √a) = a(-3/2), which increases as a decreases, so the energy-to-angular momentum transfer ratio (E/L) progressively increases without limit as a binary pair spirals in toward ultimate merger. In our early solar system, the progressive abinary decrease caused a progressive aheliocentric increase, but while the binary orbit circularized (ebinary → 0) due to tidal effects between the binary components, the heliocentric orbit was forced to become progressively more eccentric over time to accommodate the progressively-increasing E/L ratio. So, the spiral-in of the twin super-Jupiter-mass components of Binary-Companion progressively increased the heliocentric semimajor axis and eccentricity over time, overrunning Uranus orbit and driving the heliocentric 1:4 MMR through the Kuiper belt, progressively perturbing KBOs, causing the LHB of the inner solar system.
    Slotting Binary-Companion between Saturn and Uranus may provide a mechanism for the LHB of the inner solar system, by the progressive outward migration of the 1:4 MMR of Binary-Companion’s heliocentric orbit through the Kuiper belt around 4 Ga.

Equation 1: The quadrupole potential of a binary orbit


Evidence for a short-duration early pulse in a bimodal LHB, at 4.22 Ga:

    MMR perturbation of KBOs by Binary-Companion predicts a bimodal late heavy bombardment, with a narrow early pulse, as the 1:4 resonance encountered Plutinos in a 2:3 resonance with Neptune at an average semimajor axis of 39.4 AU, followed by a much-broader main pulse, as the MMR encountered the classical KBOs (cubewanos) that lie between the 2:3 resonance and the 1:2 resonance with Neptune, centered at about 43 AU. Indeed, a bimodal LHB with a bright-line early pulse is supported by lunar regolith returned by Apollo missions.
    Lunar rock in the range of 4.04–4.26 Ga, from Apollo 16 and 17, separates the formational 4.5 Ga highland crust from the late heavy bombardment (LHB) melts and breccias. (Garrick-Bethell et al. 2008) An early impact at 4.229 Ga ± 0.008 Ga has been determined from Garrick-Bethell et al. (2008), as calculated and plotted (Fig. 4) by ChatGPT 4o using the Inverse-Variance Weighted Mean with uncertainty.
    Another study reported, ” Here we report U–Pb isotopic compositions of zirconolite and apatite in coarse-grained lunar melt rock 67955, measured by ion microprobe, that date a basin-scale impact melting event on the Moon at 4.22 ± 0.01 Ga”. (Norman and Neomycin 2014)
    Černok et al. (2021) record a lunar impact at 4.2 Ga that may have formed the Serenitatis Basin, 4.2 Ga ages in samples from Apollo 14, 16 and 17.
    In addition to lunar evidence, a 4.2 Ga impact affected an LL chondrite parent body. (Trieloff et al., 1989, 1994; Dixon et al., 2004)
    The proceeding evidence suggests a short-duration early pulse of a bimodal LHB occurring at 4.22 Ga, when Binary-Companion’s outer 1:4 MMR passed through the Plutinos.

Figure 4: Evidence of an ancient lunar impact comes from Table 1 of Garrick-Bethell et al. (2008), with an inverse-variance weighted mean value of 4.229 Ga ± 0.008 Ga. This early impact provides evidence for a short-duration early pulse of a bimodal late heavy bombardment, which is a requirement for this alternative clockwork model of the solar system.
References: * Garrick-Bethell et al., (2008). [3] Takeda, H., et al. (2006) EPSL 247, 171. [4] Nyquist, L.E., et al. (2006) GCA 70, 5990. [7] Lugmair, G.W., et al. (1976) PLSC 7th, 2009. [8] Premo, W.R. and M. Tatsumoto (1992) LPSC 22nd, 381. [9] Huneke, J.C. and G.J. Wasserburg (1975) LPI VI, 417. [10] Schaeffer, O.A. and L. Husain (1974) PLSC 5th, 1541. [11] Norman, M.D., et al., LPSC 38th, 2007, abs. 1991. [12] Turner, G. and P.H. Cadogan (1975) LPSC 6th, 1509. [13] Oberli, F., et al (1979) LPI X, 490. [14] Aeschlimann, U., et al. (1982) LPI 13, 1-2. [15] Nyquist, L.E., et al. (1982) PLSC 12th, 67.


The 98º obliquity of Uranus and its moons:

    The extreme obliquity of Uranus (98º), compared to the other planets, indicates a traumatic event, which this study suggests to be the overrunning of Uranus’ orbit by the progressively increasing heliocentric period and eccentricity of Binary-Companion.
    Uranus does not possess an oversized trifurcation moon comparable to Triton at Neptune, but the dwarf planet Eris (D = 2326 km, ρ = 2.43 g/cm3) might fit the Triton (D = 2702 km, ρ = 2.06 g/cm3) profile, if Eris had lost its low-density icy crust during a passage inside the Roche limit of Uranus or one of Binary-Companion’s components, in the process of getting slung into the scattered disc. Even among the disturbed orbits of the scattered disc, Eris is an outlier, with its orbital inclination of 44°, and Eris has an anomalously high density for all trans-Neptunian objects (TNOs), with the comparably sized Pluto having a density of only 1.85 g/cm3.
    Uranus has perhaps the most well-behaved cascade of hybrid-accretion moons in the form of Miranda, Ariel, Umbriel, Titania and Oberon, which resemble the multi-planet cascades of super-Earths around many dwarf planets. This low-eccentricity, low-inclination cascade of moons, with their regular spacing and regular mass progression, is particularly surprising for a planet whose spin axis has been so severely tilted, suggesting young, in situ moon formation after the traumatic tilting event. Uranus would have lost all its moons if it had briefly passed inside or near the Roche limit of one of the super-Jupiter mass binary components of Binary-Companion. And starting fresh with no preexisting moons to disrupt a young accretion disk from the Companion-merger debris disk, Uranus could have formed a pristine cascade of moons, unparalleled in the solar system.

639 Ma spiral-in merger of Binary-Companion:
    As the binary components of Binary-Companion spiraled in due to secular perturbation from the Sun, the Hill spheres of the binary components shrank, perhaps liberating the moons from well behaved s-orbits into chaotic orbits. The moons of Binary-Companion may have consisted of 2 oversized trifurcation moons, which may have had the size and composition of mini-Neptunes, along with hybrid-accretion moons that may have been Mars sized or larger. Moons liberated into chaotic orbits could have been disrupted when passing inside the Roche limit of one of the super-Jupiter-mass components and chaotic orbits of disrupted streams could have ejected moony material from the Binary-Companion gravity well, contaminating the rest of the solar system. Additionally, moony collisions with one of the binary components could have created explosions that exceeded Binary-Companion’s Hill sphere, also contaminating the rest of the solar system. Thus, moony contamination of the solar system by the spiral-in of Binary-Companion is proposed as the cause of the extended Sturtian glaciation (717–660 Ma) of the Cryogenian Period on Earth.
    Then the subsequent Marinoan glaciation was the result of the binary spiral-in merger itself, again fogging the solar system, causing the second glaciation of the Cryogenian Period on Earth. The Marinoan glaciation’s ca. 4 Myr duration (ca. 639–635.2 Ma) is evidenced by U-Pb CA-ID-TIMS dates of tuffaceous samples (639–638 Ma) for onset, deglaciation at 635.2 Ma from the Keilberg cap dolostone, continuous Ghaub Formation stratigraphy with 10 stable grounding line cycles, and a 3–20 m compensation length scale indicating a hard snowball state over 4 Myr, spanning approximately 639 to 635 Ma. (Tasistro-Hart et al., 2025)
    Binary mergers can result in a velocity kick to the resultant merged object, when the merger explosion is asymmetrical. And since the Sun lacks a super-Jupiter-mass planet, newly merged Companion apparently acquired escape velocity in an asymmetrical merger explosion. The merger explosion left behind a high angular momentum Companion-merger debris disk that presumably spawned young, cold classical KBOs in situ beyond Neptune in ‘cold’ low-inclination low-eccentricity orbits that have not been perturbed by MMRs with Binary-Companion. Similar to the hot classical KBO population, the cold classical KBO population should also lie on the 3-oxygen-isotope terrestrial fractionation line (TFL), but unlike the hot classical population, the cold classical population is not siderophile depleted.
………………..

7. Protostellar disk and 3 debris disks


– Protostellar disk (> 4,567 Ma)—Brown Dwarf, Mars, and likely Oort cloud comets
– Trifurcation debris disk (> 4,567 Ma)—hot-classical KBOs, and likely some giant planet moons
– Solar-merger debris disk (4,567 Ma)—asteroids and likely many giant planet moons
– Companion-merger debris disk (639 Ma)—young cold-classical KBOs, and likely Uranus’ moons

– Protostellar disk (nebular reservoir) > 4,567 Ma:
    This study proposes that the solar system formed by asymmetrical FFF, followed by four generations of trifurcation. Prior to trifurcation, however, the protostellar disk may have spawned a ring of small solar system bodies (SSSBs) through gravitational collapse mediated by streaming instability. Our protostellar disk was truncated early on by asymmetrical FFF, but this truncation may have promoted its early conversion to a protoplanetary disk, spawning SSSBs with diameters larger than ~120 km (Lorek and Johansen 2023). In this scenario, a fleeting protoplanetary disk may have formed around Brown Dwarf in the interval between disk fragmentation and the trifurcation epoch, spawning SSSBs. During the early quiescent portion of the interval, hybrid accretion of the SSSBs may have formed the planet Mars. But once chaotic interplay between Brown Dwarf and the twin stellar components stirred up the disk, the relative quiescence gave way to much-higher differential velocities, causing a transition from accretion to fragmentation.  Collisional grinding and rubble-pile formation may have created a cometary size-frequency distribution, which was scattered outward to form the Oort cloud during the trifurcation epoch.

– Trifurcation debris disk (Brown-Dwarf reservoir) > 4,567 Ma:
    Centrifugal fragmentation by trifurcation is presumably a messy process, during which substantial material may be lost from trifurcating cores. This loss may predominantly occur from the twin tails trailing/bleeding from the ends of the arms of a bar-mode instability due to excessive angular momentum. In a differentiated object, gravity attracts denser material to the center of gravity, while less-dense material buoyantly rises into the ends of the arms and into the twin tails of a bar-mode instability. Trifurcation may be viewed as a fractionation process that preferentially sheds its lower density material, which this study suggests formed a trifurcation debris disk that spawned a class of SSSBs, namely the hot classical KBOs and Plutinos.
    Computer modeling of centrifugal fragmentation results in bifurcation rather than trifurcation; however, this study suggests that internal differentiation of a core undergoing centrifugal fragmentation may alter the dynamics to favor trifurcation, resulting in a diminutive residual core remaining at the center of rotation, in addition to the effectively bifurcated twin components. And this residual core is susceptible to next-generation trifurcation & etc.
    Internal differentiation of a protostellar core arises from the mechanics of its formation. Dust freefalls faster than gas in a Jeans instability because of the partial pressure support of gas, such that this study predicts that prestellar/protostellar objects are born with dust-enriched inner cores. The extent of dust enrichment in the inner core of Brown Dwarf had to be sufficient to undergo trifurcation rather than bifurcation. Trifurcation is also a decompression process, causing decompressive cooling in each generation, which promotes cohesive chemical miscibility and density stratification (sedimentation) by reducing the homogenizing effects of thermal diffusion and thermal convection. Comparing trifurcation moons by generation: 2nd-generation Titan at Saturn has a density of 1.8814 g/cm3, 3rd-generation Triton at Neptune has a density of 2.061 g/cm3, and 4th-generation Luna at Earth has a density of 3.344 g/cm3, showing a clear density progression. Triton has been modeled with a small iron-sulfide core, based on the standard model understanding of tidal dissipation as a captured object from the Kuiper belt (Tilke et al., 2026), but alternatively, perhaps metallic iron/iron sulfide could have initiated in the 3rd-generation trifurcation event, promoted by decompressive cooling.
    Thus, “igneous differentiation’ during the 3rd- and 4th-generation trifurcation apparently sequestered metallic iron and siderophile (iron-loving) elements into iron cores, which largely prevented evaporative and centrifugal loss of sequestered siderophile elements during trifurcation. Prior to igneous differentiation, the overwhelming majority of losses during trifurcation would have been in the form of volatiles (gases, liquids and ices), such that undifferentiated oxides, silicates, and metals were effectively sequestered by overlying volatiles. Thus, the silicates of the trifurcation debris disk may overwhelmingly derive from the 4th-generation trifurcation of Super-Earth, making the hot classical KBOs spawned from the trifurcation debris disk intimately related to the 4th-generation trifurcation planets (Mercury, Venus and Earth) to the extent of lying on the three-oxygen-isotope terrestrial fractionation line. Therefore, the resulting trfurcation debris disk was siderophile depleted (to the extent that it excluded nebular dust), and SSSBs spawned from the trifurcation debris disk were therefore siderophile depleted.
    The heliocentric orbit of Binary-Companion between Saturn and Uranus dictated the average specific angular momentum of the trifurcation disk, but planetary dynamics may have governed the ultimate shape and location of the disk. The four-generation trifurcation epoch was immediately followed by the dynamical unwinding of the trifurcation twins out of the gravitational well of Binary-Companion. This dynamical unwinding epoch may have systematically erased any incipient debris disk exterior to Mercury and interior to Neptune, and the pulsating gravitational potential of Binary-Sun may have precluded spawning SSSBs interior to Mercury’s orbit. But no such issue prevented an outer debris ring from forming beyond Neptune, controlled by Neptune’s strongest outer resonances. Thus, SSSB formation from the trifurcation debris disk may have largely been confined to the Kuiper belt, spawning the hot classical KBOs in situ in low-eccentricity, low-inclination “cold” orbits that were subsequently perturbed into their present “hot” orbits by the sweep of Binary-Companion’s 4:1 mean motion resonance (MMR) swept through the Kuiper belt, resulting in the late heavy bombardment (LHB).
    The coloration of the Plutinos and scattered disc indicates membership in the hot classical population, with the young cold classical population bounded by Nuptune’s outer 3:2 and 2:1 resonances. The scattered disc were not formed in situ, but were presumably scattered outward from the classical Kuiper belt by the outward migration of Binary-Companion’s 4:1 MMR during the LHB. But the bimodal timing of the late heavy bombardment (§ 6) appears to indicate that the Plutinos preexisted the perturbation of the hot classical population and therefore must have formed in situ. The absence of a cold classical contribution to the Plutinos, presumably from the 639 Ma spiral-in merger of Binary Companion, suggests an extraordinary origin of the Plutios. In that regard, the unwinding of the trifurcation twins may have effectively plowed trifurcation debris gas outward ahead of Neptune, causing a pileup of dust and gas in Neptune’s outer 3:2 resonance, spawning the Plutinos in situ.
    So, the hot classical KBOs spawned by streaming instability from the trifurcation debris disk should be siderophile depleted and lie on or very near the three-oxygen-isotope terrestrial fractionation line. Whether any of the giant planets captured sufficient dust and gas from the incipient trifurcation debris disk to spawn moons is an open question. The Galileo spacecraft measured Ganymede’s gravity field that seems to indicate an iron-rich core, so the Galileon planets around Jupiter, anyway, may not have formed from the trifurcation debris disk.

– Solar-merger debris disk with SLRs formed by energetic-particle spallation (a hybrid reservoir combining a nebular component and a solar-merger component) 4,567 Ma:
   Binary-Companion perturbed the stellar components of Binary-Sun, causing them to spiral in and merge at 4,567 Ma, as the t = 0 defining event in the radioactive cosmochronology of the solar system.
    While many of the SLRs of the early solar system may be accommodated by galactic chemical evolution (GCE), two of the isotopes with the shortest half-lives, ⁴¹Ca and ²⁶Al, appear to require late nucleosynthesis. The standard model leans toward late nearby injection from a supernova or a Wolf-Rayet star, but in situ formation by spallation has also been entertained. Indeed, ¹⁰Be cannot be formed by stellar nucleosynthesis, requiring a spallation origin.
    As the twin magnetized protostars spiraled inward, their magnetic fields became increasingly compressed, stretched and twisted, storing energy drawn from the gravitational collapse of their mutual orbit. When oppositely directed magnetic fields encountered one another, rapid magnetic reconnection released this stored energy, accelerating charged particles to energies capable of producing short-lived radionuclides (SLRs) by spallation. The flattened common envelope offered the least resistance along the rotation axis, potentially allowing energetic particles and magnetically driven outflows to escape through the poles as outflows or jets.
    ³He-rich particle irradiation has been proposed as a mechanism for forming the short-lived radionuclides (SLRs) ²⁶Al and ⁴¹Ca in the early Solar System (Lee et al., 1998; Herzog et al., 2011). Magnetic reconnection can preferentially accelerate ³He. In modern solar energetic particle (SEP) events, ³He can be enhanced over its natural abundance by factors of 10⁴. Impulsive magnetic events tend to produce a relatively soft particle-energy spectrum. A low-energy cutoff in the few-MeV range may be necessary to avoid overproducing ⁴¹Ca relative to ²⁶Al.
    Thus, in the early stages of the Binary-Sun merger, impulsive events, generally characterized by soft spectra and enhanced ³He abundances presumably formed ²⁶Al and ⁴¹Ca, which may have homogenized in the common envelope to form the canonical (²⁶Al/²⁷Al)₀ ≈ 5 × 10⁻⁵ ratio of the early solar system. And outflows from a homongenized common envelope condensed refractory minerals to form classical CAIs with canonical ²⁶Al.
    A contrasting population of hibonite-rich CAIs, including platy hibonite crystals (PLACs), records little or no initial ²⁶Al despite evidence for live ¹⁰Be in many specimens. These inclusions also preserve exceptionally large nucleosynthetic isotope anomalies, particularly in neutron-rich ⁴⁸Ca and ⁵⁰Ti, with both positive and negative deviations reaching tens to hundreds of parts per thousand relative to terrestrial isotope ratios. Kööp et al. (2016) investigated these Ca–Ti anomalies and their relationship to oxygen isotopes, while Kööp et al. (2018) identified excess ³He and ²¹Ne attributable to energetic-particle irradiation after the inclusions had formed. PLAC-like CAIs are generally interpreted as predating the canonical ²⁶Al-rich CAIs, but this study proposes the opposite sequence: their formation during the final merger of the twin stellar components.
    A possible explanation for their unusual isotopic compositions begins with grain-size sorting during the original gravitational collapse. Bate and Lorén-Aguilar (2017) demonstrated that dust grains smaller than approximately 10 μm remain closely coupled to collapsing gas, whereas larger grains can become concentrated toward the center and midplane. In their simulations, 100 μm grains produced central dust-to-gas ratios exceeding 0.1, while 1 mm grains could locally become more abundant than the gas. If presolar dust populations differed in both grain size and nucleosynthetic isotope composition, this aerodynamic sorting could have established spatial differences in the distribution of isotopically anomalous carrier grains.
    In the bilateral disk fragmentation proposed for asymmetrical FFF, dust settling could initially produce a vertical grain-size gradient relative to the disk midplane, while spiral density waves could further concentrate aerodynamically responsive grains within spiral-arm pressure maxima. For such sorting to produce the isotopic heterogeneity observed in PLAC-like CAIs, at least one of the twin stellar fragments would need to inherit a nonuniform distribution of isotopically distinct grains and convert that distribution into a radial compositional gradient during its subsequent collapse and accretion. The resulting nucleosynthetic isotope gradient would then need to survive the vaporization and ionization of the original dust grains, requiring that convective and other internal mixing remain sufficiently limited before the final Binary-Sun merger.
    Several physical mechanisms might act together to preserve such a gradient. Rapid accretion, particularly when a substantial fraction of the accretion energy is retained, can produce inflated, high-entropy protostars with radiatively stable interiors. A mass disparity between the twin components, such as 0.7 M☉ and 0.3 M☉ rather than equal masses, could result in different accretion histories, internal entropy profiles, and convective evolution. Preferential incorporation of refractory dust into the central regions could also establish an inward-increasing mean molecular-weight gradient. Under the Ledoux criterion, such a gradient provides stabilizing compositional buoyancy that can oppose convection driven by the radial temperature gradient. This effect could help preserve an isotopically heterogeneous central region even if the surrounding stellar envelope becomes convective.
    The subsequent orbital evolution of unequal-mass twins could introduce additional thermal effects. As the components spiral inward, the more massive star might undergo Roche-lobe overflow, transferring material through the inner L₁ Lagrange point toward its lower-mass companion. Depending on the donor’s internal structure and the rate of mass loss, the resulting decompression and adiabatic expansion could reduce its central temperature and deuterium-burning luminosity, potentially weakening a source of convective driving. During common-envelope evolution, orbital energy dissipated through shocks, turbulence, and possibly magnetic reconnection could also raise the entropy of the surrounding envelope, potentially inhibiting convective penetration into the stellar cores. These effects would compete with tidal shear, turbulent mixing, and other disturbances associated with the accelerating inspiral. Preservation of the original isotopic gradients would therefore require that the stabilizing effects, together with the short interval before merger, outweigh the accompanying mixing processes.
    The final merger of the twin stellar cores within their common envelope may have generated an energetic-particle spectrum capable of producing ¹⁰Be by spallation in material associated with polar outflows from the merging cores. These outflows may also have expelled material retaining distinct nucleosynthetic isotope compositions inherited from the original presolar dust reservoirs. Cooling and condensation of this heterogeneous material could then have produced PLAC-like CAIs exhibiting large positive and negative ⁴⁸Ca and ⁵⁰Ti anomalies, together with low initial ²⁶Al/²⁷Al ratios. Production of ¹⁰Be would need to precede or accompany incorporation into the refractory inclusions, whereas subsequent irradiation of the already condensed inclusions in a cooler environment could account for their measured excesses of spallogenic ³He and ²¹Ne.
    Chondrules dated by U-corrected Pb–Pb chronology indicate that chondrule formation began contemporaneously with CAI formation at approximately t = 0. Yet chondrules generally record substantially lower initial (²⁶Al/²⁷Al)₀ ratios than the canonical value of (5.23 ± 0.13) × 10⁻⁵ found in CAIs. Notably, Pb–Pb-dated chondrules with ages indistinguishable from CAIs yield a mean initial ratio of approximately 4.8 × 10⁻⁶, roughly an order of magnitude lower (Bollard et al., 2019). While classical CAIs presumably inherited canonical ²⁶Al from the well-mixed common envelope, chondrules formed through the melting of dust aggregates with a substantial presolar contribution deficient in ²⁶Al.
    Stellar-merger outflows may not have possessed sufficient mass and specific angular momentum to form a debris disk extending into Jupiter’s inner mean-motion resonances, but continuing infall from the solar envelope with high specific angular momentum combined with merger outflow formed a hybrid disk, designated the solar-merger debris disk, which in turn spawned the asteroid belt. Stable oxygen isotopes provide a potentially useful tracer of these two contributions. On a three-oxygen-isotope diagram of δ¹⁷O versus δ¹⁸O, the Carbonaceous Chondrite Anhydrous Mineral (CCAM) array has a slope of approximately 0.94, consistent with a near-slope-one relationship that may reflect mixing between reservoirs with differing Δ¹⁷O values. In the proposed hybrid disk, these reservoirs comprised relatively ¹⁶O-depleted presolar nebular material with Δ¹⁷O ≈ 0‰ and relatively ¹⁶O-enriched solar-merger material, represented provisionally by the Genesis solar value of Δ¹⁷O ≈ −28.4‰. Canonical CAIs typically register Δ¹⁷O ≈ −24 ± 2‰, consistent with a predominantly ¹⁶O-rich solar reservoir, with a minor nebular contribution from isotopically heavier oxygen. If the relative abundance of merger-derived material decreased outward, the hybrid disk could have developed a broad radial oxygen-isotope gradient, contributing to the contrasting compositions of achondrite, ordinary-chondrite and carbonaceous-chondrite parent bodies. In this interpretation, relatively merger-rich materials were preferentially incorporated into inner-disk parent bodies, while more distant parent bodies incorporated progressively greater proportions of inherited nebular material. The parent bodies of CI carbonaceous chondrites that lack refractory inclusions may represent the outermost parent bodies in this trend, containing little or no solar-merger input, which some models suggest may have formed beyond 15 AU. The designation of solar-merger contribution as ¹⁶O-enriched is relative to terrestrial standards, but the isotopic contrast may principally reflect ¹⁶O-depletion in nebular condensates (including Earth) caused by CO self-shielding rather than nuclear enrichment of ¹⁶O in solar material.
    Cosmochemical models commonly attribute the mass-independent oxygen-isotope fractionation responsible for distinct ¹⁶O-rich and ¹⁶O-poor reservoirs to CO self-shielding. This photochemical process occurs when abundant C¹⁶O preferentially absorbs the far-ultraviolet radiation responsible for its own photodissociation, allowing relatively greater photodissociation of the less abundant C¹⁷O and C¹⁸O isotopologues. The resulting ¹⁷O- and ¹⁸O-enriched atomic oxygen can enter other oxygen-bearing species, particularly H₂O, which may subsequently freeze onto dust grains. This produces complementary reservoirs of relatively ¹⁶O-rich CO and ¹⁶O-depleted water ice. Although the initial fractionation depends on spatially varying ultraviolet irradiation, the resulting oxygen-isotope differences become partitioned among distinct chemical carriers. Subsequent physical redistribution of gas and dust need not erase this partitioning, provided chemical exchange does not completely equilibrate the reservoirs. Consequently, distinct oxygen-isotope reservoirs could have been inherited from the presolar molecular cloud and nebula rather than having been generated locally by irradiation from the newly formed Sun.
    This study suggests that CAIs formed through condensation of stellar-merger ejecta onto relic presolar dust aggregates that served as nucleation sites. The resulting inclusions could therefore combine relatively homogeneous merger-derived condensates with heterogeneous presolar components carrying distinct nucleosynthetic isotope signatures. Fine-grained CAIs may have experienced comparatively little melting, whereas many coarse-grained CAIs underwent substantial igneous processing. Within this framework, FUN CAIs (fractionation and unidentified nuclear effects) might represent an extreme manifestation of the same heterogeneous precursor and condensation processes, rather than an entirely separate formation mechanism. The working hypothesis suggests that normal CAIs with canonical or near-canonical ²⁶Al formed within the principal hot stellar outflows, where they acquired substantial merger-derived condensates and were lofted well above the disk plane. By comparison, FUN CAIs may have formed near the margins of these outflows, receiving smaller condensate contributions and experiencing less extensive lofting. Differences in outflow trajectories and ballistic return times could have affected their subsequent exposure to the intense activity of the post-merger Sun. Under favorable geometrical and shielding conditions, FUN CAIs returning more rapidly toward the inner disk might have undergone additional evaporation, melting and isotopic fractionation, whereas some ordinary CAIs remained farther from the most intense processing regions. Chondrules could likewise have formed during energetic post-merger outbursts capable of transiently melting dust aggregates, with the newly merged Sun possibly going through a flare star phase following the Binary-Sun merger. This hypothesis therefore predicts that merger-condensate contribution, initial ²⁶Al abundance, nucleosynthetic isotope anomalies, ballistic return time and subsequent thermal processing may be correlated rather than independent properties of CAIs.
    This study further proposes that the hybrid solar-merger debris disk spawned the parent bodies of the asteroid belt, potentially through dust concentration by streaming instability followed by gravitational collapse. Differentiated parent bodies supplied many achondrites, whereas less extensively processed parent bodies preserved chondritic material, including chondrules and refractory inclusions. Early-accreting asteroids containing abundant live ²⁶Al could undergo substantial internal heating and differentiation, whereas bodies accreting after several ²⁶Al half-lives (t₁/₂ = 7.17 × 10⁵ years) generally experienced less radiogenic heating and were more likely to preserve primitive mineral assemblages. Within the proposed heterogeneous hybrid disk, the degree of asteroid differentiation depended on ²⁶Al abundance, along with with asteroid size and composition.

– Companion-merger debris disk (Binary-Companion reservoir) 639 Ma:
   This study proposes that the twin super-Jupiter-mass components of the 1st-generation trifurcation orbited the Sun between Saturn and Uranus for almost 4 billion years as Binary-Companion. But the binary configuration was not stable: the Sun perturbed Binary-Companion to spiral inward until the components merged at 639 Ma, creating the ‘Companion-merger debris disk’ that fogged the solar system and caused the Marinoan glaciation on Earth. The Binary-Companion merger apparently resulted in an asymmetrical merger-explosion kick that gave the newly merged Companion escape velocity from the Sun. The Companion-merger debris disk spawned the young, cold classical KBO population by gravitational collapse facilitated by streaming instability between Neptune’s outer 3:2 and 2:1 resonances. The ‘cold’ aspect of cold classical KBOs indicates that these KBOs formed in situ in low-inclination low-eccentricity orbits that have not been perturbed into ‘hot’ orbits like the hot population. Binary KBOs are much more common in the cold classical population than in the hot classical population, as would be expected if the perturbation that increased inclination and eccentricity of the hot population into hot orbits also tended to disrupt binary KBOs. And the prevalence of cold classical KBOs in wide binary orbits composed of similar-sized and similar-colored components is strong evidence for formation in binary pairs by gravitational collapse (Nesvorný et al., 2010).
   The earlier, longer Sturtian glaciation (716–660 Ma) of the Cryogenian Period may not have been one continuous icehouse.  Minsky et al. (2025) concludes “that the Sturtian glaciation was not one long Snowball or Slushball, but a highly dynamic state oscillating between climate extremes”.  This “oscillation”/fluctuation fits with intermittent fogging of the solar system for 56 million years by Binary-Companion repeatedly shredding its moons as the components spiraled inward. As the super-Jupiter-mass components of Binary-Companion spiraled in, the Hill spheres of the binary components shrank, progressively liberating moons from their formational orbits into chaotic 3-body orbits that may have resulted in ejection from the binary system, collision with one of the binary components, or shredding inside the Roche limit. And the period between the Sturtian and Marinoan glaciations was the period between shredding the innermost moons and the binary merger itself.
   Brown Dwarf accreted both ¹⁶O-depleted nebular dust and ice along with ¹⁶O-enriched gas as a result of CO self-shielding, but in the diffuse cores of the twin components of Binary-Companion, silicates et al. likely exchanged oxygen atoms repeatedly with the immersive gas over the nearly 4 billion year lifespan of Binary Companion. Thus, silicates incorporated into cold classical KBOs from the Companion-merger debris disk were likely far less ¹⁶O-depleted than the hot classical KBO population and therefore likely have a markedly negative Δ¹⁷O value.
   Additionally, the cold classical KBO population should not be siderophile depleted, if there had been no igneous differentiation in either Brown Dwarf or in the 1st-generation trifurcation components.  While the residual core of the 1st-generation trifurcation inherited a greater relative percentage of metallicity than the twin components that became Binary-Companion, the siderophile percentage of the metallicity should have been equivalent..
   Thus, the hot classical KBO population should have a markedly negative Δ¹⁷O value compared to terrestrial standards, but similar to terrestrial material in its homogeneity, which is unlike the heterogeneous Δ¹⁷O in chondrites. And hot classical KBOs should have a solar abundance of siderophile elements, unlike the siderophile-depleted hot classical population.
………………..

8. Venusian cataclysm


    Venus is suggested here to be Earth’s twin from a fourth-generation trifurcation that formed Venus with an oversized trifurcation moon in a retrograde orbit. Prograde planetary rotation with a retrograde moony orbit causes an energy and angular momentum transfer from the moon’s orbit to the planet’s rotation, causing retrograde moony orbits to decay over time. Venus’ former retrograde moon presumably spiraled in to merge with the planet sometime in the past, resulting in the Venusian cataclysm that resurfaced the planet and resulted in Venus’ slight retrograde rotation. For Venus’ current retrograde orbit to be the result of a spiral-in merger with a former trifurcation moon in a retrograde orbit requires that the trifurcation moon’s orbit had greater angular momentum than Venus’ former prograde rotation.

A former retrograde trifurcation moon of Venus:
    The simplified version of trifurcation leaves out a twin pair of trifurcation moons, which are gravitationally bound to their respective binary components as moons. The complete version is designated, ‘trifurcation+2’ (§ 5).
    Computer models of bar mode instability include spiral tails, trailing from the two ends of the bar. In trifurcation+2, these spiral tails are suggested to pinch off into a pair of trifurcation moons when the central bar trifurcates. These moons are gravitationally bound to their respective binary planetary components, namely Venus and Earth in the 4th generation trifurcation. But these trifurcation moons are not born with angular momentum with respect to their twin binary components. Presumably an orbital close encounter of the 4th-generation trifurcation with either Uranus or Neptune gave the binary Venus-Earth system a kick, which imparted a prograde orbit to Earth’s trifurcation moon and by symmetry a retrograde orbit to Venus’ trifurcation moon. In this way, Earth acquired its oversized trifurcation moon, Luna, in a prograde moony orbit, and by symmetry, Venus acquired a similar-sized trifurcation moon in a retrograde moony orbit, where retrograde moons are doomed to ultimately spiral in and merge with their host planet due to tidal interactions.

Timing of the Venusian cataclysm:
    The nearly-random spatial distribution of Venus’ low crater count suggests ‘recent’ igneous resurfacing of the entire planet, estimated to have occurred 300–500 Myr by Price and Suppe (1994) or 300–1000 Myr by McKinnon et al. (1997).
    A cataclysm the scale of a large moony merger with our closest planet will not have left Earth completely unscathed.  A large moony merger with Venus will have created a heliocentric debrs ring centered on Venus, but the solar wind would have quickly dispersed the gaseous portion of a ring, leaving behind only particulates and larger aggregates. Micrometeorites from the debris ring burning up in Earth’s upper atmosphere would have reflected sunlight back into space, possibly causing a glaciation on Earth.
    But even massive protoplanetary disks only last several million years, and a thin Venusian debris disk would have been much briefer than that, likely pointing to the notably brief Gaskiers glaciation at 579 Ma, with a duration of only 340 k.y. (Pu et al., 2016).  By comparison, the Baykonurian glaciation (tied to the 549–530 Ma Baykonur Formation) near the Proterozoic-Phanerozoic boundary, the Hirnantian glaciation (460–420 Ma) near the Ordovician-Silurian boundary, and the late Paleozoic icehouse, formerly known as the Karoo ice age, (360–255 Ma) were all vastly longer in duration.
    Pancake-shaped coronae on Venus, caused by mantle upwelling, may be evidence of a protracted digestion of its former moon, with Venus’s sulfurous atmosphere presumably sustained by continued volcanic outgassing. “Sulphur dioxide is a million times more abundant in the atmosphere of Venus than that of Earth, possibly as a result of volcanism on Venus within the past billion years.” (Marcq et al 2013)
    And if the Gaskiers Formation were attributable to a brief inner solar system debris disk, one would expect the Gaskiers Formation to contain spherules from micrometeorites with a terrestrial isotopic composition.

Avalon explosion of Ediacaran biota:
    It’s tempting to attribute the Avalon explosion of Ediacaran biota that occurred only 4 million years after the Gaskiers glaciation to a Venusian origin, possibly by direct contamination of Earth by Venusian biota.
    As a trifurcation moon in a decaying retrograde orbit reached the Roche limit, planetary gravity would have stripped the moon of its loose regolith, fogging the atmosphere and creating a vastly-deeper Venusian glaciation than any on Earth, likely freezing surface oceans solid to the bottom. Kilometer-scale fragments of ocean ice would make ideal cocoons for seeding the solar system with Venusian microorganisms, and possibly Venusian metazoans in the form of egg cases or resting cysts (acritarchs). The difficulty with this suggestion is identifying a plausible mechanism for boosting large chunks of sea ice to escape velocity, when deorbiting moony meteorites would only have had half the specific kinetic energy of escape velocity.
    Molecular clocks indicate Metazoa originated in the range of 850-650 Ma (Cunningham et al., 2016), and if so, then the absence of earlier evidence of (soft bodied) Metazoa is inexplicable, given the abundant preservation of acritarchs from this period. Additionally, “recent molecular clock analyses estimate that the crown‐groups of most animal phyla did not originate until the Cambrian. The presence of crown members of most animal phyla in the Ediacaran is therefore not an expectation of most molecular clock studies” (Cunningham et al., 2016). Thus, the absence of soft-bodied Metazoa preservation prior to Gaskiers glaciation from molecular clocks is inexplicable for a terrestrial origin of Ediacaran metazoa, and the absence of crown groups prior to the Cambrian is expected from molecular clocks, with both findings consistent with Venusian contamination during the Gaskiers glaciation. But terrestrial contamination by a Venusian cataclysm assumes a degree of earlier microorganism interchange between Venus and Earth, to prevent Ediacaran metazoa from appearing genetically extraterrestrial.
    Transplanted extraterrestrial lifeforms would encounter unoccupied ecological niches on a new world, promoting rapid evolution of pioneering organisms, particularly for more advanced organisms. Additionally, genetic adaptation to extraterrestrial characteristics, such as altered gravitational acceleration, magnetic field, ocean chemistry, tidal dynamics, solar radiation, and duration of days and years would also promote rapid evolution, possibly explaining both the Avalon explosion of Ediacaran biota and the Cambrian explosion only 33 million years later.

    Trifurcation ideology predicts a former retrograde moon at Venus, whose merger neatly unifies
1) the retrograde rotation of Venus,
2) the ‘recent’ resurfacing of Venus,
3) the continuing volcanism and sulfurous atmosphere on Venus,
4) the Gaskiers glaciation on Earth,
5) and possibly the sudden origin of the Ediacaran biota following the Gaskiers glaciation.
………………..

9. Solar system summary


    Four planets of the solar system exhibit a narrow range of axial tilts in their heliocentric orbits, ranging from 23.44° for Earth to 28.32° for Neptune, which suggests a solar system-wide effect.  The most momentous event following the unwinding of trifurcation was the spiral in merger of former Binary-Sun at 4,567 Ma.  The merger event sloughed off a percentage of the combined mass of the binary stellar components, reducing the solar gravity, which increased the semimajor axes and periods of all heliocentric orbits.  Conservation of angular momentum presumably caused the axial tilts in the 20–30° range, when the planets lurched outward, possibly compensating for a mismatch in orbital angular momentum between the old and new orbits.  Jupiter is a notable exception, with its small 3.13° axial tilt.

Brown Dwarf:
    ‘Brown Dwarf’ was the original protostellar core of the solar system, whose protostellar accretion was interrupted by symmetrical FFF, causing gravitational fragmentation of a high-angular-momentum stellar-mass protostellar disk, which may have been shaped like a bar-mode instability, forming twin, stellar-mass disk-fragmentation objects that evolved into Binary-Sun. Orbital interplay between the disk-fragmentation objects and Brown Dwarf induced centrifugal fragmentation of Brown Dwarf (trifurcation), ending its brief existence.
    Mars may have formed as a hybrid-accretion object around Brown Dwarf, prior to the trifurcation epoch, and the unincorporated small solar system bodies formed by streaming instability may have been scattered outward as comets to form the Oort cloud.
– The protoplanetary disk reservoir presumably consists of Mars and the Oort cloud comets.
– The solar-merger debris disk reservoir consists of the asteroids and chondrites of the inner solar system.
– The Brown Dwarf reservoir consists of the 7 trifurcation planets, the hot classical KBOs from the trifurcation debris disk, and the young (639 Ma) cold classical KBOs from the Companion-merger debris disk. Everything from the Brown Dwarf reservoir should lie on the 3-oxygen-isotope Brown Dwarf fractionation line, which we know as the terrestrial fractionation line.

Binary-Sun:
    A massive high-angular-momentum accretion disk, that may have been shaped like a bar-mode instability, underwent gravitational fragmentation, designated symmetrical FFF, forming twin disk-fragmentation objects that evolved into Binary-Sun. The resulting ternary system, consisting of twin stellar-mass disk-fragmentation objects around the diminutive, brown-dwarf-mass protostellar core (Brown Dwarf) was dynamically unstable, resulting in chaotic orbital interplay. Equipartition of kinetic energy of the ternary system increased the orbital kinetic energy of Brown Dwarf at the expense of the twin components of Binary-Sun in orbital close encounters, and this study suggests that equipartition of kinetic energy also has a rotation component, causing the trifurcation of Brown Dwarf.
    Binary-binary resonance chasing (perturbation) of Binary-Sun by the trifurcation components caused the stellar-mass components of Binary-Sun to spiral in and merge at 4,567 Ma, creating a brief LRN. Jupiter’s angular momentum created a solar-merger debris disk from the LRN debris, which spawned the asteroid belt, presumably by streaming instability. Stellar-merger nucleosynthesis may have formed a couple of the SLRs of the early solar system, notably 26Al and 41Ca. And the stellar merger could also have caused the 16O enrichment by briefly pushing the merging cores deeper into the CNO cycle (§ 7).

Symmetrical FFF, followed by 4 generations of trifurcation:
    Symmetrical FFF is like 0th-generation trifurcation, if both symmetrical FFF and trifurcation occur in bar-mode instabilities and both form ternary (sub)systems. Symmetrical FFF presumably occurs in high-angular-momentum collapsing cores, with their protostellar disks distorted into triaxial shapes, possibly resembling bar-mode instabilities. And symmetrical FFF, like trifurcation, creates ternary (sub)systems, composed of a twin pair in orbit around a diminutive core, initially at the center of rotation. In our solar system, all the twin pairs from both symmetrical FFF and trifurcation were transitory, with the 2 most-massive twin pairs (Binary-Sun and Binary-Companion) spiraling in and merging, while the 3 least-mass twin pairs (Jupiter-Saturn, Uranus-Neptune, and Venus-Earth) spiraled out and separated.
1) Symmetrical FFF – Binary-Sun + Brown Dwarf (protostar)
2) First-generation trifurcation – Binary-Companion + SUPER-Jupiter (residual core)
3) Second-generation trifurcation – Jupiter-Saturn + SUPER-Neptune (residual core)
4) Third-generation trifurcation – Uranus-Neptune + SUPER-Earth (residual core)
5) Fourth-generation trifurcation – Venus-Earth + Mercury (residual core)
    And the resulting trifurcation debris disk presumably spawned the hot classical KBOs beyond Neptune, influenced by Neptune’s MMRs.
    Then binary-binary resonance chasing, predominantly driven by Binary-Sun, unwound the binary pairs except for Binary-Companion.

Binary-Companion:
    The super-Jupiter-mass twin-binary components of Binary-Companion did not separate like the binary components of the three subsequent trifurcation generations, which briefly created a quaternary system composed Binary-Companion in a wide binary orbit around Binary-Sun, with a Sun-Companion separation of ~ 15 AU (between Saturn and Uranus).
    Following the Binary-Sun merger at 4,567 Ma, continuing perturbations from the newly merged Sun caused the components of Binary-Companion to spiral in over time. This spiral in progressively increased the heliocentric eccentricity and semimajor axis of Binary-Companion over time, causing Binary-Companion to overrun the orbit of Uranus, resulting in Uranus’ severe axial tilt and likely stripping Uranus of its moons.
    The progressively increasing heliocentric semimajor axis of Binary-Companion presumably caused the 1:4 heliocentric MMR of Binary-Companion to migrate outward through the Kuiper belt, perturbing Plutinos at 4.22 Ga, followed by cubewanos from 4.1-3.8 Ga, resulting in a bimodal late heavy bombardment (LHB) of the inner solar system, with a short-duration early pulse.
    The spiral-in of the super-Jupiter-mass components progressively ejected or accreted their own moons, fogging the solar system, which caused the Sturtian glaciation of Snowball Earth. Ultimately, the binary components merged at 639 Ma in an asymmetrical merger explosion, giving newly merged Companion escape velocity from Sun, with the merger explosion causing the Marinoan glaciation of the Cryogenian Period.
    The resulting Companion-merger debris disk spawned the cold classical KBOs in situ. It also likely formed some of the giant planets’ hybrid-accretion moons, most notably Uranus’ well-behaved cascade of moons.

Mercury:
    Mercury is presumably the residual core of the 4th generation trifurcation of SUPER-Earth, which is borne out by its proportionately more massive iron core than either Venus or Earth. Alternatively, if the residual core of the 4th generation trifurcation did not survive the trifurcation epoch, by being ejected from the (inner) solar system or swallowed by the Sun, Mercury could be a hybrid accretion planet formed from the solar-merger debris disk.

Venus:
    Venus is presumed to be the twin of Earth, from the fourth-generation trifurcation of SUPER-Earth.
    At formation by trifurcation, Venus acquired a ‘trifurcation moon’, which was the twin of Earth’s trifurcation Moon, Luna. In the dynamics of the trifurcation epoch, Luna was arbitrarily injected into a prograde orbit, and by symmetry, Venus’ trifurcation moon was necessarily injected into a retrograde orbit, which was doomed to undergo orbital decay due to tidal effects from the planet. The decaying retrograde orbit spiraled in and merged with Venus, presumably at 579 Ma, causing in the ‘Venusian cataclysm’ (§ 2), which resulted in Venus’ slight retrograde rotation and resurfacing of the entire planet. The moony merger briefly fogged the inner solar system, causing Gaskiers glaciation on Earth. And Venus’ contemporary volcanism and sulfurous atmosphere may represent continuing repercussions from the merger.
    A 579 Ma date for the Venusian cataclysm offers the possibility of terrestrial contamination by Venusian metazoa, possibly explaining the sudden appearance of Ediacaran biota 4 million years after the Gaskiers glaciation.

Earth:
    Earth is presumed to be the twin of Venus, from the fourth-generation trifurcation of SUPER-Earth, with its prograde-orbit trifurcation moon, Luna.
    Binary-binary resonance chasing apparently caused Venus-Earth-Mercury to spiral out and escape from Uranus-Neptune.  Continued resonance chasing caused Jupiter-Saturn to spiral out from Binary-Companion to be captured by Binary-Sun by way of Binary-Companion’s (inside) L1 Lagrange point, while Venus-Earth-Mercury were still embedded in Jupiter-Saturn’s gravity well.  Additional resonance chasing caused Venus-Earth-Mercury to spiral out from Jupiter-Saturn to be captured by Binary-Sun by way of Jupiter-Saturn’s (inside) L1 Lagrangian point.  And a final round of resonance chasing caused Venus, Earth, and Mercury to spiral out from their common barycenter to be captured by Binary-Sun into solitary heliocentric orbits.
    The Great Unconformity on Earth is presumably the result of glacial erosion during the Cryogenian glaciations.  The Sturtian glaciation was presumably caused by the fogging of the solar system by the cannibalization of Binary-Companion’s moons during the spiral-in of the super-Jupiter-mass, due to perturbation by the Sun. And the Marinoan glaciation was caused by the fogging of the solar system when the binary components ultimately merged at 639 Ma.
    Earth may have been contaminated by Venusian lifeforms at 579 Ma during the Venusian cataclysm, possibly explaining the sudden appearance of Ediacaran biota 4 million years after the Gaskiers glaciation (§ 2).
    The basement rock of the continental tectonic plates on Earth is suggested to be extraterrestrial in origin, from aqueously-differentiated hot classical KBOs that impacted Earth during the LHB (The Extraterrestrial Origin of the Continental Tectonic Plates).

Mars:
    Mars is the only solar-system planet not formed by trifurcation. Mars presumably formed by hybrid accretion around Brown Dwarf, prior to its trifurcation by Binar-Sun. This would make Mars the oldest planet in the solar system.

Jupiter:
    Jupiter is presumed to be the twin of Saturn, from the second-generation trifurcation of SUPER-Jupiter.
    Like Venus and Neptune, Jupiter presumably once possessed a former trifurcation moon in a doomed retrograde orbit that spiraled and merged with the gas giant, presumably at 4,562 Ma. The most compelling evidence for a moony merger of a large trifurcation moon with Jupiter is enstatite chondrites, with a 29I–129Xe age of 4,562.3 +/- 0.4 (Gilmour et al. 2009), which are the only chondrites to lie on the terrestrial fractionation line. Evidence for a local heating event comes from dolomites formed by melting water ice in CI chondrites, with a 53Mn–53Cr age of 4,563.8–4,562.5 (Fujiya et al. 2013). And the chemically-reduced nature of enstatite chondrites may be explained by plasma immersion in the luminous red nova phase (LRN) of Binary-Sun merger at 4,567 Ma.
    The deuterium/hydrogen (D/H) ratio of Saturn is lower than that of Jupiter by 0.71% + 0.22% – 0.15%, contrary to standard-model predictions of a higher ratio (Pierel et al. 2017). But if the retrograde trifurcation moon merger explosion overflowed Jupiter’s Roche sphere at 4,562 Ma, atmospheric hydrogen would have been extensively fractionated, due to the high 2-to-1 mass ratio between deuterium and protium.

Saturn:
    Saturn is presumed to be the twin of Jupiter from the second-generation trifurcation of SUPER-Jupiter, with Titan as its prograde-orbit trifurcation moon. As at Jupiter, Saturn also exhibits a neat cascade of planemo hybrid-accretion moons from one or more of the solar system debris disks, but Saturn’s hybrid accretion moons are relatively much smaller than Jupiter’s Galilean moons, even considering the planetary mass difference.
    The standard model for Saturn’s rings suggests a young origin, with an estimated age in the range of 100–400 million years. Alternatively, a ~ 650 Ma origin from the Companion-merger debris disk is not proportionally so far beyond the 400-million-year upper limit.

Uranus:
    Uranus is presumed to be the twin of Neptune from the third-generation trifurcation of SUPER-Neptune. During the trifurcation epoch, binary resonance chasing caused Uranus-Neptune to escape from Jupiter-Saturn and then from Binary-Companion, via Binary-Companion’s outer L2 Lagrange point.
    Uranus’ severe axial tilt of 98° and the apparent absence of a trifurcation moon indicates a significant dynamic event, which was presumably the overrunning of Uranus’ orbit by Binary-Companion at an unknown date.  Triton (R = 1,354 km) at Neptune is significantly larger than Uranus’ largest moon, Titania (R = 788 km), which apparently indicates a missing prograde trifurcation moon.
    Uranus could have lost its trifurcation moon and any hybrid accretion moons from a close encounter with former Binary-Companion. When Binary-Companion overran Uranus’ orbit, proximity to a super-Jupiter-mass component of Binary-Companion would have briefly shrunk Uranus’ Hill sphere, which could have caused its moons to wander away. And this clean slate may have paved the way for Uranus’ particularly well-behaved cascade of hybrid-accretion moons from the young, 639 Ma Companion-merger debris disk.

Neptune:
    Neptune is presumed to be the twin of Uranus from the third-generation trifurcation of SUPER-Neptune, with Triton as its retrograde-orbit trifurcation moon. Triton is in a decaying retrograde orbit that will one day spiral-in to merge with the planet. Neptunes lacks large hybrid-accretion moons like Uranus, which could indicate that Triton’s retrograde orbit disrupted their formation. If this is the case, this indicates that Triton is older than the trifurcation debris disk (as required by the trifurcation ideology) and therefore was not captured more recently from the Kuiper belt, as hypothesized by the standard model.
    Neptune’s heliocentric resonances apparently shaped the early trifurcation debris disk and the late Companion-merger debris disk, determining the in situ formation by streaming instability of the hot and cold classical KBOs.

Asteroids and chondrites:
    Asteroids and chondrites are presumed to have formed in situ by streaming instability in relation to Jupiter’s strongest inner resonances from the solar-merger debris disk at 4,567 Ma. Streaming instability is understood to form objects ~ 120 km in diameter and larger, such that smaller asteroids may be fragments of larger asteroids or rubble pile asteroids that gravitationally coalesced following asteroid collisions.
    Refractory calcium aluminum inclusions (CAIs), found in chondrites, contain canonical concentrations of 26Al. If 26Al is attributable to stellar-merger nucleosynthesis from the spiral-in merger, then a canonical concentration suggests its origin from the merging stellar cores where nucleosynthesis occurred. And core material is most likely to escape in polar jets emitted during the merger process. Chondrules, by comparison, formed over the next 3 million years, perhaps when intermittent solar flares melted coagulated dust particles into igneous chondrules, during a brief flare star phase of the young Sun following its binary spiral-in merger.
    Early-forming asteroids with live SLRs melted internally, whereas chondrites formed over the next 5 million years, largely after SLRs had decayed away, avoided igneous differentiation, preserving chondrules, presolar grains, CAIs et al. Some chondrites exhibit aqueous alteration, indicating warming events in the asteroid belt.

Hot classical KBOs:
    The trifurcation debris disk lay on the 3-oxygen-isotope TFL, as part of the Brown Dwarf reservoir, and it also had a siderophile-depleted composition, due to the internal differentiation of the trifurcating components that created the debris disk. Thus, hot classical KBOs spawned from the trifurcation debris disk should be siderophile depleted and lie on the TFL. A trans-Neptunian component of the debris disk may have had an inner solar system counterpart that spawned small solar system bodies in the present-day asteroid belt, but the subsequent LRN phase of the spiral-in merger of Binary-Sun at 4,567 Ma presumably vaporized these possible early objects.
    Hot classical KBOs were originally spawned in ‘cold’, low-inclination low-eccentricity orbits that were subsequently perturbed into their present ‘hot’, high-inclination high-eccentricity orbits by the outward migration of a MMR with former Binary-Companion, presumably the 1:4 MMR. Objects from the hot classical population that were perturbed/scattered to a greater extent created the scattered disk, the extended scattered disc, detached objects, and bombarded the inner solar system during the LHB.
    Large KBOs underwent ‘aqueous differentiation’ at formation by streaming instability that melted water ice, forming sedimentary silicate cores from precipitates that crystallized from solution. Again, the basement rock of the continental tectonic plates on Earth is suggested to be extraterrestrial in origin, from the sedimentary silicate cores of hot classical KBOs that impacted Earth during the LHB (The Extraterrestrial Origin of the Continental Tectonic Plates).

Cold classical KBOs:
    The spiral-in merger of former Binary-Companion ended in a merger explosion that created the trans-Neptunian Companion-merger debris disk at 639 Ma, which was sculpted by Neptune’s outer orbital resonances. The Companion-merger debris disk spawned cold classical KBOs in situ in ‘cold’ low-inclination low-eccentricity orbits. Whether or not the Companion-merger debris disk spawned any objects in the asteroid belt is an open question. In the asteroid belt, 1 Ceres is the odd man out, with its dwarf planet designation, icy composition, unfrozen subsurface brine, lack of large craters, and conspicuous lack of a collisional family, suggesting the outside possibility of a young age from the young Companion-merger debris disk.
    Binary KBOs are more likely to be members of the cold classical population, presumably due to early perturbation of the hot classical population by Binary-Companion. Cold classical binary systems are typically composed of similar-size and similar-color binary pairs in wide binary orbits, indicative of formation by gravitational instability (Nesvorný et al., 2010). Additionally, the cold classical population tends to be red in coloration, while the hot classical population is more heterogeneous, tending toward bluish hues.
    Presumably few if any cold classical KBOs in stable, low-inclination low-eccentricity orbits, have been perturbed into the inner solar system.

The Pluto system § 4:
    The dwarf planet Pluto system presumably formed in situ by streaming instability in Neptune’s outer 2:3 resonance. Unofficially, the Pluto-Charon system is sometimes called a double dwarf planet system, due to its orbital barycenter lying beyond Pluto’s surface.
    The Pluto system presumably formed by symmetrical FFF, despite the 8:1 mass ratio between Pluto and Charon. Pluto has 4 additional much smaller moons that appear constitute 2 sets of binary pairs that may point to formation by trifurcation, with Nix-Hydra as the first-generation trifurcation twin-binary pair and Styx-Kerberos as the second-generation trifurcation twin-binary pair. Formation by symmetrical FFF and trifurcation would make the Pluto system a miniature version of our solar system.
………………..

10. The predictive and explanatory power of FFF-trifurcation ideology


    This alternative planet- and star-formation hypothesis attempts to unify formerly disparate solar-system phenomena into a deterministic clockwork mechanism that is more fertile than the standard model—with greater explanatory and predictive power and greater falsifiability. However, this alternative approach is speculative, lacking mathematical foundations or computer simulations. If fertile hypotheses are easy to formulate, then this study deserves no notice; but if they are fiendishly difficult to devise unless generally sound, then it may warrant further attention. Lest its clockwork nature be held against it, note that both the Grand Tack and the Nice model are also clockwork models in a similar sense.
    Several guiding principles of this alternative philosophy are:
– Primary processes are generally superior to more ad hoc secondary mechanisms,
– Nature generally favors catastrophism over gradualism, and
– Sound theories are fertile theories, tending to unify formerly disparate phenomena.
Primary processes are generally superior to more ad hoc secondary mechanisms because ad hoc secondary mechanisms are often introduced to rescue a theory rather than to explain the phenomenon independently. Nature generally favors catastrophism over gradualism, since catastrophism accelerates the increase in entropy. And fertile theories tend to unify formerly disparate phenomena, reducing complexity.

Three sets of twin planets § 5:
+++ The trifurcation (Russian nesting doll) model was devised to explain the three sets of twin planets of our highly unusual solar system in a deterministic manner that is more predictive and more falsifiable than the standard model.  Trifurcation requires symmetrical FFF to initiate the trifurcation process, which predicts a former Binary-Sun that spiraled in and merged and also predicts a more-massive fourth set of twin planets that have since disappeared.  The clockwork dynamics of this model unify a number of otherwise disparate Solar System phenomena, eight of which are described below.  And the FFF model was minimally extended to bring order to the growing complexity of giant planets and brown dwarfs being discovered. The primary process of trifurcation is particularly economical in its starting conditions, forming the Sun and nine planets (Binary-Companion, Jupiter-Saturn, Uranus-Neptune, and Mercury) from only three foundational objects (Binary-Sun and Brown Dwarf) that must be uniquely specified by state variables. Four generations of trifurcation and all their downstream consequences are unified within the alternative SS clockwork model.
– – – The standard model places no significance on the three sets of twin planets in our solar system.  And it largely relies on secondary planet migration and a splintering of planet and brown dwarf formation mechanisms to explain the clustering and scarcity of giant planets and brown dwarfs in orbital period–planet mass/planet radii phase space. The standard model is not economical in its starting conditions, requiring separate sets of state variables for each planet.

Bimodal late heavy bombardment (LHB) § 6:
+++ Former Binary-Companion perturbed Plutinos in a brief, early bimodal pulse at 4.22 Ga, followed by the more-sustained perturbation of cubewanos from 4.1-3.8 Ga in the broader, main bimodal pulse, by means of the progressive outward migration of the 1:4 mean-motion resonance of Binary-Companion through the Kuiper belt, which was driven by the spiral in of its super-Jupiter-mass binary components. This study requires a bimodal LHB with a narrow early pulse, consistent with the orbital-period–density distribution of trans-Neptunian objects (TNOs). The Serenitatis Basin may be the origin of the 4.2 Ga lunar ages in samples from Apollo 14, 16 and 17 (Černok et al., 2021), consistent with an early bimodal pulse. The outward migration of a MMR through the Plutinos and then cubewanos predicts and requires a bimodal LHB, and the LHB and its downstream consequences are unified within the greater alternative solar system (SS) clockwork model.
– – – The Nice Model recognizes a LHB, but not a bimodal early pulse around 4.22 Ga. The LHB and its downstream consequences are unified within the clockwork Nice Model.

Bimodal orbital-period distribution of hot and cold Jupiters §3:
+++ Asymmetrical FFF presumably forms gaseous planets and possibly low-mass brown dwarfs by a flip-flop mechanism, wherein the planet forms as a pre/protostellar central core, which is flip-flopped into a planetary satellite orbit around a much-more massive disk-fragmentation object that becomes the new protostar at the center of rotation. Hot Jupiters presumably form by disk fragmentation of protostellar disks (accretion disks), whereas more-distant cold Jupiters presumably form by disk fragmentation of more distant pseudodisks, resulting in a bimodal population of giant gaseous planets with a 10–100 day orbital-period valley in between. Asymmetrical FFF forms gaseous objects in planetary satellite orbits, presumably ranging in mass from mini-Neptunes through super-Jupiters and possibly up to low-mass brown dwarfs. The high metallicity of stars hosting hot Jupiters is consistent with the disk fragmentation of dusty protostellar disks. Separate sources neatly accommodate if not predict bimodal populations.
– – – Hierarchical accretion theory suggests that planetary migration causes some giant planets formed in the Goldilocks zone to migrate inward to become hot Jupiters; however, a migration mechanism struggles to explain discrete populations, with the 10–100 day orbital-period valley in between. And the Zink & Howard (2023) alternative explanation for hot and cold Jupiters formed in pairs with Coplanar High-eccentricity Migration has the difficulty of explaining why this two-planet configuration and dynamic interaction results in elevated metallicity in the host stars.

4 Mj valley in gas-giant planets §3:
+++ If giant planets form as prestellar/protostellar central cores, then asymmetrical FFF may be inhibited during the pithy first hydrostatic core (FHSC) phase, due to viscous engagement between the pithy FHSC and the surrounding accretion disk, temporarily hindering the disk-core feedback necessary for disk fragmentation. This identifies the primary process causing the 4 Mj valley in gas-giant planets.
– – – The standard model suggests that giant planets < 4 Mj formed by accretion, while giant planets > 4Mj formed by disk instability. This requires a splintering of the standard model to explain a single phenomenon.

Bimodal distribution of hot and cold classical KBOs §7:
+++ This alternative clockwork model suggests that the bimodal KBO population is due to the cold and hot populations having formed in situ from two separate debris disks separated by almost 4 billion years. The old, hot classical KBO population formed from the > 4,567 Ma trifurcation debris disk, while the young cold population formed from the 639 Ma Companion-merger debris disk. The old hot population has been perturbed into “hot” high-inclination high-eccentricity orbits by the outward migration of the 4:1 MMR of Binary-Companion through the TNOs from 4.22–3.8 Ga, due to the perturbation of its binary components by Binary-Sun, whereas the “cold” population is in its unperturbed formational state. This alternative model explains the bimodal orbital properties, color differences and relative proportion of binary pairs based on formation from separate reservoirs, and it makes strong falsifiable predictions of their ages, oxygen-isotope composition, and degree of siderophile depletion. And the bimodal debris disks and bimodal SSSB populations are unified within the alternative SS clockwork model.
– – – The Nice model explains the hot classical population as having been perturbed outward by the outward migration of Neptune, where Neptune stopped short of perturbing the cold classical population. This predicts compositional differences between the hot and cold populations based on radial formational distance from the Sun.

Trifurcation moons §5:
+++ Trifurcation by centrifugal fragmentation may additionally form twin trifurcation moons, which are gravitationally bound to their respective twin trifurcation planets. Rotational spin up that progresses to a bar-mode instability creates twin tails that trail from the bar-mode ends. During trifurcation, these twin tails may gravitationally detach to become their own Roche lobes, forming twin moons gravitationally bound to their respective twin planets. Then subsequent kicks imparted to the trinary system by the older, larger twins that induced trifurcation impart orbital rotation to the twin moons around their respective twin planets, necessarily imparting a prograde orbit to one twin moon and a retrograde orbit to the other. Titan as a prograde trifurcation moon at Saturn presupposes a twin retrograde trifurcation moon at Jupiter, retrograde Triton at Neptune presupposes a former prograde moon at Uranus, and prograde Luna at Earth presupposes a former retrograde moon at Venus. The former retrograde moon at Jupiter may have spiraled in and merged with the planet at 4,562 Ma, forming enstatite chondrites that lie on the 3-oxygen isotope terrestrial fractionation line. The former prograde moon at Uranus may have been lost when Binary-Companion overran Uranus’ orbit prior to 639 Ma. And Venus’ former retrograde moon may have spiraled in and merged with Venus at 579 Ma. Trifurcation moons formed in the primary process of trifurcation, which is unified within the alternative SS clockwork model.
– – – The standard model theory of Earth’s oversized Moon is Giant Impact by a Mars-mass object that requires a nearly identical isotopic composition to Earth. This is an ad hoc secondary process.

Venusian cataclysm, causing Venus’ retrograde rotation §8:
+++ Moons raise lagging tides on planets with supersynchronous rotation, which, in the case of a moon with a retrograde orbit, pulls the moon backwards in its orbit, causing the orbit to progressively decay. The trifurcation mechanism suggests that each twin trifurcation planet is born with a trifurcation moon, and that subsequent dynamics imparts a prograde orbit to one moon with respect to its trifurcation planet and a retrograde orbit to the other. Luna at Earth acquired a prograde orbit, requiring Venus’ trfurcation moon to acquire a retrograde orbit. Venus’ retrograde moon presumably merged with the planet at 579 Ma, jolting Venus into retrograde rotation, with the explosive merger entirely resurfacing the planet and causing continuing coronae eruptions accompanied by sulfurous outgassing. A Venusian cataclysm so near Earth would have had a spillover effect, fogging Earth’s upper atmosphere with micrometeorite dust, presumably causing the brief Gaskiers glaciation on Earth. And if the Venusian cataclysm seeded Earth with Venusian biota, then the environmental stress of planet hopping would have promoted explosive evolution, possibly explaining new stem groups in the Ediacaran and new crown groups in the Cambrian. The dynamic evolution of trifurcation moons potentially unifies various Venusian and terrestrial phenomena under the primary process of trifurcation and its downstream effects, which is further unified within the alternative SS clockwork model.
– – – Because tidal locking of Venus with the Sun cannot create retrograde rotation, the standard model proposes one or more giant impacts causing Venus retrograde rotation, which represents an ad hoc secondary mechanism.

Solar-merger spallation nucleosynthesis §7:
+++ As the twin magnetized protostars spiraled inward, their magentic fields became stretched and twisted, resulting in numerous magnetic reconnection episodes in the common envelope phase that accelerated charged partilcles to energies sufficient to produce SLRs by spallation. ³He-rich particle irradiation has been proposed as a mechanism for forming the short-lived radionuclides (SLRs) ²⁶Al and ⁴¹Ca in the early Solar System (Lee et al., 1998; Herzog et al., 2011). And the canonical concentration of ²⁶Al in CAIs could represent homogenization of ²⁶Al in the tenuous common envelope. Then during the final merger event itself, more intense proton irradiation may have formed ¹⁰Be by spallation in polar jets launched from the merging cores. Potential energy of the spiral-in merger was partially dissipated magnetically in magnetic reconnection events, forming SLRs by spallation as a downstream consequence of the primary process of the Binary-Sun merger. And the primary process of the Binary-Sun merger and all its downstream consequences is itself unifed with the alternative SS clockwork mechanism.
– – – The standard model suggests a late addition of 26Al and 41Ca from an AGB star or a Wolf-Rayet star, requiring a fortuitous, nearby late addition into our natal nebula, which represents an ad hoc secondary mechanism.

Bimodal Snowball Earth §6:
+++ The suggested spiral-in merger of our former Binary-Companion at 639 Ma explains the Marinoan glaciation as the fogging of the solar system by the Companion-merger debris disk. And the earlier Sturtian glaciation (716–660 Ma) may have been caused by the super-Jupiter-mass compnents of Binary-Companion accreting the moons of the binary components during the spiral-in process. This could have fogged the solar system intermittently causing Earth to fluctuate between warm and cold episodes during the extended Sturtian glaciation. This represents an external primary process driving terrestrial glaciations, which unifies this terrestrial phenomenon with the alternative SS clockwork model.
– – – The scientific consensus is that the Sturtian and Marinoan glaciations were most likely triggered by a combination of tectonic reorganization and massive volcanic activity strongly linked to the Franklin Large Igneous Province (LIP) and the breakup of Rodinia. This represents a terrestrial primary process driving glaciation, which unifies glaciations with tectonic and volcanic activity, but it begs the question of why one particular tectonic breakup and igneous province should be associated with the deepest glaciation in Earth’s history, when other tectonic reorganization and volcanic activity aren’t associated with cooling events.

Uranus’ 98° axial tilt §6:
+++ This alternative clockwork ideology suggests that Binary-Companion overran Uranus’ orbit, due to the perturbation of the super-Jupiter-mass components of Binary-Companion by the Sun. Uranus was presumably forced into a higher heliocentric orbit, with its 98° axial tilt (obliquity) part of the conservation of system angular momentum. This offers a primary process explanation for the phenomenon, unifying Uranus’ severe axial tilt into the alternative SS clockwork model.
– – – The standard model suggests that a giant impact may have tilted Uranus’ rotational axis, which represents an ad hoc secondary mechanism.
……………….

References


Albrecht, Simon H.; Marcussen, Marcus L.; Winn, Joshua N.; Dawson, Rebekah I. & Knudstrup, Emil, (2021), A Preponderance of Perpendicular Planets, The Astrophysical Journal Letters, Volume 916, Number 1.

Banerjee, Bihan; Narang, Mayunk; Manoi, P.; Henning, Thomas, Tyangi, Himanshu; Surya, Arun; Nayak, Prasanta K. & Tripathi, Mihir, (2024), Astron. J., 168, 1.

Bate, Matthew R., (2011), Collapse of a molecular cloud core to stellar densities: the formation and evolution of pre-stellar discs, Monthly Notices of the Royal Astronomical Society, Volume 417, Issue 3, November 2011, Pages 2036–2056.

Bate, Matthew R. & Lorén-Aguilar, Pablo, (2017), On the dynamics of dust during protostellar collapse, Monthly Notices of the Royal Astronomical Society, Volume 465, Issue 1, Pages 1089–1094.

Bertaux, Jean-Loup & Ivanova, Anastasiia, (2022), A numerical inversion of m sin i exoplanet distribution: the sub-Saturn desert is more depleted than observed and hint of a Uranus mass gap, MNRAS Vol. 512, Issue 4, pp. 5552-5571.

Bollard, Jean; Kawasaki, Noriyuki; Sakamoto, Naoya; Olsen, Mia Bjørg Stolberg; Itoh, Shoichi; Larsen, Kirsten K.; Wielandt, Daniel; Schiller, Martin; Connelly, James N.; Yurimoto, Hisayoshi & Bizzarro, Martin, (2019), Combined U-corrected Pb-Pb dating and ²⁶Al-²⁶Mg systematics of individual chondrules – Evidence for a reduced initial abundance of ²⁶Al amongst inner Solar System chondrules, Geochimica et Cosmochimica Acta, Volume 260, Pages 62–83.

Burbine, Thomas H. & O’Brien, Kevin M., 2004, Determining the possible building blocks of the Earth and Mars, Meteoritics & Planetary Science 39, Nr 5, 667–681 (2004).

Chen, Xuepeng; Arce, H´ector. G.; Zhang, Qizhou; Bourke, Tyler L.; Launhardt, Ralf; Jørgensen, Jes K.; Lee, Chin-Fei; Forster, Jonathan B.; Dunham, Michael M.; Pineda, Jaime E. & Henning, Thomas, (2013), SMA Observations of Class 0 Protostars: A High-Angular Resolution Survey of Protostellar Binary Systems

Campins, H. & Swindle, T. D., (1998), ARE THERE COMETARY METEORITES?, Lunar and Planetary Science XXIX.

Carlos, M., Melendez, J., Spina, L., dos Santos, L. A., Bedell, M., Ramirez, I., Asplund, M., Bean, J. L., Yong, D., Yana Galarza, J., & Alves-Brito, A, (2019), The Li-age correlation: the Sun is unusually Li deficient for its age, Monthly Notices of the Royal Astronomical Society, 485(3), 4052–4059.

Černok, Ana; White, Lee F.; Anand, Mahesh; Tait, Kimberly T.; Darling, James R.; Whitehouse, Martin; Miljković, Katarina; Lemelin, Myriam; Reddy, Steven M.; Fougerouse, Denis; Rickard, William D. A.; Saxey, David W. & Ghent, Rebecca, (2021), Lunar samples record an impact 4.2 billion years ago that may have formed the Serenitatis Basin, Communications Earth & Environment volume 2, Article number: 120 (2021).

Chatterjee, Sourav & Tan, Jonathan C., (2013), INSIDE-OUT PLANET FORMATION, arXiv:1306.0576.

Curie, Thayne, (2005), Hybrid Mechanisms for Gas/Ice Giant Planet Formation, ApJ 629 (2005) 549-555.

Czavalinga, D. R.; Mitnyan, T.; Rappaport, S. A.; Borkovits, T.; Gagliano, R.; Omohundro, M.; Kristiansen, M. H. K. & Pal, A., (2023), Newly identified compact hierarchical triple system candidates using Gaia DR3, A&A 670 Jan 2023.

Demory, Brice-Olivier; Ehrenreich, David; Queloz, Didier; Seager, Sara; Gilliland, Ronald; Chaplin, William J.; Proffitt, Charles; Gillon, Michael; Gunther, Maximilian N.; Benneke, Bjorn; Dumusque, Xavier; Lovis, Christophe; Pepe, Francesco; Segransan, Damien; Triaud, Amaury & Udry, Stephane, (2015), Hubble Space Telescope search for the transit of the Earth-mass exoplanet α Centauri B b, MNRAS 450, 2043–2051 (2015).

Dixon, E. T., Bogard, D. D., Garrison, D. H., & Rubin, A. E., (2004), Geochim. Cosmochim.
Acta, 68, 3779.

Dong, Subo; Xie, Ji-lin; Zheng, Zheng & Luo, Ali, (2018), LAMOST telescope reveals that Neptunian cousins of hot Jupiters are mostly single offspring of stars that are rich in heavy elements, PNAS, 2018, 115 (2) 266-271.

Espinoza-Retamal, Juan I.; Stefansson, Gudmundur; Petrovich, Cristobal; Brahm, Rafael; Jordan, Andres; Sedaghati, Elyar; Lucero, Jennifer P. & Suc, Vincent, (2024), HATS-38 b and WASP-139 b join a growing group of eccentric hot Neptunes on polar orbits, arXiv:2406.18631v1.

Franchi I. A., Wright I. P., Sexton A. S. & Pillinger C. T., (1999), The oxygen-isotopic composition of Earth and Mars, Meteorit. Planet. Sci. 34, 657-661.

Fujiya, Wataru; Sugiura, Naoji; Sano, Yuji Sano & Hiyagon, Hajime, 2013, Mn–Cr ages of dolomites in CI chondrites and the Tagish Lake ungrouped carbonaceous chondrite, Earth and Planetary Science Letters Volume 362, 15 January 2013, Pages 130-142.

Herzog, Gregory F.; Caffee, Marc W.; Faestermann, Thomas; Hertenberger, R.; Korschinek, Gunther; Leya, Ingo; Reedy, Robert C. & Sisterson, J. M., (2011), Cross Sections from 5 to 35 MeV for the Reactions natMg(³He,x)²⁶Al, ²⁷Al(³He,x)²⁶Al, natCa(³He,x)⁴¹Ca, and natCa(³He,x)³⁶Cl: Implications for Early Irradiation in the Solar System, Meteoritics & Planetary Science, Volume 46, Number 10, pp. 1427–1446.

Garrick-Bethell, I.; Fernandez, V. A.; Weiss, B. P.; Shuster, D. L. & Becker, T. A., (2008), 4.2 BILLION YEAR OLD AGES FROM APOLLO 16, 17, AND THE LUNAR FARSIDE: AGE OF THE SOUTH POLE-AITKEN BASIN?, Early Solar System Impact Bombardement, Earth Planet. Sci. Lett. 388, 387–388 (2008).

Gilmour J. D. et al., (2009), Meteoritics & Planetary Science 44:573-580.

Gomez, Yilen Gomez Maqueo Chew & Stassun, Keivan G., (2009), Near-Infrared Light Curves of the Brown Dwarf Eclipsing Binary 2MASS J05352184–0546085: Can Spots Explain the Temperature Reversal?, ApJ 699(2).

Hsieh, Cheng-Han; Mardones, Diego; Dunham, Michael M.; Li, Hui; Offner, Stella S. R., (2025), CAMPOS II. The Onset of Protostellar Disk Substructures and Planet Formation, Astronomy & Astrophysics, manuscript no. aanda (submitted).

Inoue, Shigeki & Yoshida, Naomi, (2019), Spiral arm instability — III. Fragmentation of primordial protostellar discs, arXiv:1908.09576v2.

Keller, C. Brenhin; Husson, Jon M.; Ross, N. Mitchell; Bottke, William F.; Gernon, Thomas M.; Boehnke, Patrick; Bell, Elizabeth A.; Swanson-Hysell, Nicholas L. & Peters, Shanan E., (2018), Neoproterozoic glacial origin of the Great Unconformity, PNAS January 22, 2019 116 (4) 1136-1145.

Kööp, Levke; Davis, Andrew M.; Nakashima, Daisuke; Park, Changkun; Krot, Alexander N.; Nagashima, Kazuhide; Tenner, Travis J.; Heck, Philipp R. & Kita, Noriko T., (2016), A Link between Oxygen, Calcium and Titanium Isotopes in ²⁶Al-Poor Hibonite-Rich CAIs from Murchison and Implications for the Heterogeneity of Dust Reservoirs in the Solar Nebula, Geochimica et Cosmochimica Acta, Volume 189, pp. 70–95.

Kööp, L.; Heck, Philipp R.; Busemann, Henner; Davis, Andrew M.; Greer, Jennika; Maden, Colin; Meier, Matthias M. M. & Wieler, Rainer, (2018), High Early Solar Activity Inferred from Helium and Neon Excesses in the Oldest Meteorite Inclusions, Nature Astronomy, Volume 2, Number 9, pp. 709–713.

Larson, Richard B., (1969), NUMERICAL CALCULATIONS OF THE DYNAMICS OF A COLLAPSING PROTO-STAR, MNRAS (1969) 145, 271-295.

Lee, Typhoon; Shu, Frank H.; Shang, Hsien; Glassgold, Alfred E. & Rehm, K. E., (1998), Protostellar Cosmic Rays and Extinct Radioactivities in Meteorites, The Astrophysical Journal, Volume 506, Number 2, pp. 898–912.

Lellouch, E.; Bezard, B.; Fouchet, T.; Feuchtgruber, H.; Encrunaz, T. & de Graauw, T., (2001), The deuterium abundance in Jupiter and Saturn from ISO-SWS observations.

Li-Yun, Jin; Yun, Li & Ming, Yang, 1991, RNAA of trace iridium in Precambrian-Cambrian boundary samples by thiourea type chelate resin separation, Journal of Radioanalytical and Nuclear Chemistry, September 1991, Volume 151, Issue 1, pp 107–111.

Li, Zhi-Yun; Banerjee, Robi; Pudritz, Ralph E.; Jorgensen, Jes K.; Shang, Hsien, Kranopolsky, Ruben & Maury, Anaelle, (2014), The Earliest Stages of Star and Planet Formation: Core Collapse, and the Formation of Disks and Outflows.

Ma, Bo & Ge, Jian, (2014), Statistical properties of brown dwarf companions: implications for different formation mechanisms, MNRAS 439, 2781–2789 (2014).

Machida, Masahiro N.; Inutsuka, Shu-ichiro & Matsumoto, Tomoaki, (2011), RECURRENT PLANET FORMATION AND INTERMITTENT PROTOSTELLAR OUTFLOWS INDUCED BY EPISODIC MASS ACCRETION, ApJ 729:42 (17pp), 2011 March 1.

Marchi, S. et al., (2016), The missing large impact craters on Ceres, Nature Communications volume 7, Article number: 12257 (2016).

Masunaga, Hirohiko; Miyama, Shoken M. & Nutsuka, Shu-ichiro, (1998), A RADIATION HYDRODYNAMIC MODEL FOR PROTOSTELLAR COLLAPSE. I. THE FIRST COLLAPSE, ApJ Volume 495, Number 1.

Mazeh, Tsevi; Holczer, Tomer & Faigler, Simchon, (2016), Dearth of short-period Neptunian exoplanets – a desert in period-mass and period-radius planes, A&A 589, A75.

Minster, J. F.; Ricard, L. P. & Allegre, C. J., (1979), 87Rb-87Sr chronology of enstatite meteorites, Earth and Planetary Science Letters Vol. 44, Issue 3, Sept. 1979.

Mogan, Saahit & Zanazzi, J. J., (2024), Concealing Circumbinary Planets with Tidal Shrinkage, arXiv:2412.01616.

Mousis, Olivier; Deleuil, Magali; Aguichine, Artyom; Marcq, Emmanuel; Naar, Hoseph; Lorena Acuna Aguirre; Brugger, Bastien; & Goncalves, Thomas, (2020), Irradiated Ocean Planets Bridge Super-Earth and Sub-Neptune Populations, The Astrophysical Journal Letters, 896:L22 (5pp), 2020 June 20.

Nesvorný D., Morbidelli A., (1998), THREE-BODY MEAN MOTION RESONANCES AND THE CHAOTIC STRUCTURE OF THE ASTEROID BELT, The Astronomical Journal, 116:3029-3037. 1998 December.

Nesvorný, D., Morbidelli, A. (1999). Mean Motion Resonances in the Asteroid Belt. In: Henrard, J., Ferraz-Mello, S. (eds) Impact of Modern Dynamics in Astronomy. Springer, Dordrecht.

Nesvorný, David; Youdin, Andrew N. & Richardson, Derek C., (2010), Formation of Kuiper Belt Binaries by Gravitational Collapse, The Astronomical Journal 140 (2010) 785.

Noll, Keith S.; Grundy, William M.; Stephens, Denise C.; Levison, Harold F. & Kern Susan D., (2008), Evidence for Two Populations of Classical Transneptunian Objects: The Strong Inclination Dependence of Classical Binaries, arXiv:0711.1545.

Norman, Marc D. & Nemchin, Alexander A., (2014), A 4.2 billion year old impact basin on the Moon: U–Pb dating of zirconolite and apatite in lunar melt rock 67955, Earth and Planetary Science Letters 388 (2014) 387–398.

Ofek, E. O.; Kulkarni, S. R.; Rau, A.; Cenko, S. B.; Peng, E. W.; Blakeslee, J. P.; Cote, P.; Ferrarese, L;. Jordan, A.; Mei, S.; Puzia, T.; Bradley, L. D.; Magee, D. & Bouwens, R., (2007), The Environment of M85 optical transient 2006-1: constraints on the progenitor age and mass, arXiv:0710.3192.

Pearson, Samuel G. & McCaughrean, Mark J., (2023), Jupiter Mass Binary Objects in the Trapezium Cluster, arXiv:2310.01231.

Pierel, J. D. R.; Nixon, C. A.; Lellouch, E; Fletcher, L. N.; Bjoraker, G. L.; Achterberg1,, R. K.; Bézard, B.; Hesman, B. E.; Irwin, P. G. J. & Flasar, F. M., 2117, D/H Ratios on Saturn and Jupiter from Cassini CIRS, The Astronomical Journal, Volume 154, Number 5.

Porter, Simon B. & Canup, Robin M., (2023), Orbits and Masses of the Small Satellites of Pluto, Planet. Sci. J. 4 120

Pu, Judy P.; Bowring, Samuel A.; Ramezani, Jahandar; Myrow, Paul; Raub, Timothy D.; Landing, Ed; Mills, Andrea; Hodgin, Eben & Macdonald, Francis A., (2016), Dodging snowballs: Geochronology of the Gaskiers glaciation and the first appearance of the Ediacaran biota, Geology (2016) 44 (11): 955–958.

Rau, A.; Kulkarni, S. R.; Ofek, E. O. & Yan, L., (2007), Spitzer Observations of the New Luminous Red Nova M85 OT2006-1, ApJ Volume 659, Issue 2, pp. 1536-1540.

Rice, Malena; Wang, Songhu & Laughlin, Gregory, (2022), Origins of Hot Jupiters from the Stellar Obliquity Distribution, The Astrophysical Journal Letters, Volume 926, Issue 2, id.L17, 8 pp.

Santos, N. C.; Adibekyan, V.; Figueira, P.; Andreasen, D. T.; Barros, S. C. C.; Delgado-Mena, E.; Demangeoun, O.; Faria J. P.; Oshagh, M.; Sousa, S. G.; Viana, P. T. P. & Ferreira, A. C. S., (2017), Observational evidence for two distinct giant planet populations, Astronomy and Astrophysics 603, May 2017.

Scheeres, D. J.; Ostro, S. J.; Werner, R. A.; Asphalug, E. & Hudson, R. S., (2000), Effects of Gravitational Interactions on Asteroid Spin States, Icarus, Volume 147, Issue 1, September 2000, Pages 106-118.

Stassun, Keivan G.; Mathieu, Robert D. & Valenti, Jeff A., (2007), A Surprising Reversal of Temperatures in the Brown-Dwarf Eclipsing Binary 2MASS J05352184−0546085, ApJ 664(2) April 2007.

Stevenson, D. J., Harris, A. W. & Lunine, J. I., (1986), Satellites (Tucson, AZ: Univ. Arizona Press), 39.

Tasistro-Hart, Adrian R.; Macdonald, Francis A.; Crowley, James L.; Schmitz, Mark D., (2025), Four-million-year Marinoan snowball shows multiple routes to deglaciation, PNAS 122(18), e2418281122.

Tilke, Lana J.; Trinh, Kevin T.; O’Rourke, Joseph G., (2026), A modern dynamo at Triton as a consequence of its capture by Neptune, Nature Astronomy, 10(8), 1119-1128.

Tobin, John et al., (2016), A Triple Protostar System Formed via Fragmentation of a Gravitationally Unstable Disk, Nature 538, 483-486 (2016).

Trieloff, M., Jessberger, E. K., & Oehm, J., (1989), Meteoritics, 24, 332.

Trieloff, M., Deutsch, A., Kunz, J., & Jessberger, E. K., (1994), Meteoritics, 29, 541.

Tychoniec, Lukasz; Tobin, John J.; Karsaka, Agata; Chandler, Claire; Dunham, Michael M.; Harris, Robert J.; Kratter, Kaitlin M.; Li, Zhi-Yun; Looney, Leslie W.; Melis Carl; Perez, Laura M.; Sadavoy, Sarah I.; Segura-Cox, Dominique; & van Dishoeck, Ewine F., (2018), THE VLA NASCENT DISK AND MULTIPLICITY SURVEY OF PERSEUS PROTOSTARS (VANDAM). IV. FREE-FREE EMISSION FROM PROTOSTARS: LINKS TO INFRARED PROPERTIES, OUTFLOW TRACERS, AND PROTOSTELLAR DISK MASSES.

Unger, N.; Ségransan, D.; Barbato, D.; Delisle, J. -B.; Sahlmann, J; Holl, B.; and Udry, S., (2023), Exploring the brown dwarf desert with precision radial velocities and Gaia DR3 astrometric orbits, A&A Volume 680, December 2023.

Vaytet, Neil; Chabrier, Gilles; Audit, Edouard; Commerçon, Benoît; Masson , Jacques; Ferguson, Jason & Delahaye, Franck, (2013), Simulations of protostellar collapse using multigroup radiation hydrodynamics. II. The second collapse, Astronomy & Astrophysics manuscript no. vaytet-20130703 c ESO 2013 July 22, 2013.

Werner, Stephanie C., (2009), The global martian volcanic evolutionary history, Icarus 2001 (2009) 44-68.

Wilson, P. A., Hébrard, G., Santos, N. C., et al. (2016). The SOPHIE search for northern extrasolar planets. IX. Populating the brown dwarf desert. Astronomy & Astrophysics, *588*, A144.

Wittenmyer, Robert A.; O’Toole, Simon J.; Jones, Hugh R. A.; Tinney, C. G.; Butler, R. Paul; Carter, Brad D. & Bailey, Jeremy, (2010), The Frequency of Low-Mass Exoplanets. II. The ‘Period Valley’, The Astrophysical Journal, Volume 722, Number 2.

Young, Alison K., (2023), Insights into the first and second hydrostatic core stages from numerical simulations, Front. Astron. Space Sci. 10:1288730 (2023).

Zink, Jon K. & Howard, Andrew W., (2023), Hot Jupiters Have Giant Companions: Evidence for Coplanar High-Eccentricity Migration, The Astrophysical Journal Letters, Oct 2023.

Leave a Reply